Welcome to Detroit Sports Forum!

By joining our community, you'll be able to connect with fellow fans that live and breathe Detroit sports just like you!

Get Started
  • If you are no longer able to access your account since our recent switch from vBulletin to XenForo, you may need to reset your password via email. If you no longer have access to the email attached to your account, please fill out our contact form and we will assist you ASAP. Thanks for your continued support of DSF.

Big Boards

LKP

Senior Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2012
Messages
16,723
Here is my big board so there is no question the order of talent I see

1. Aidan Hutchinson EDGE Michigan
2. Kayvon Thibodeaux EDGE Oregon
3. Ahmad Gardner CB Cincinnati
4. Evan Neal OT Alabama
5. Kyle Hamilton S Notre Dame
6. CB Derek Stingley LSU
7. Travon Walker EDGE Georgia
8. Charles Cross OT Mississippi State
9. Tyler Linderbaum OT Iowa State
10. Ikem Ekwonu OT NC State
11. Jameson Willaims WR Alabama
12. Nakobe Dean ILB Georgia
13. Garret Wilson WR Ohio State
14. Drake London WR USC
15. Devin Lloyd ILB Utah
16. QB Malik Willis Liberty
17. QB Kenny Pickett Pittsburgh
18. Treylon Burks WR Arkansas
19. Jordan Davis DT Georgia
20. Jermaine Johnson EDGE Florida State
21. Daxton Hill S Michigan
22. George Karlaftis EDGE Purdue
23. Bernhard Raimman OT CMU
24. Trent McDuffie CB Washington
25. Andrew Booth Jr CB Clemson
26. Boye Mafe EDGE Minnesota
27. Chris Olave WR Ohio State
28. Lewis Cine S Georgia
29. Devonte Wyatt Dline Georgia
30. Roger McCreary CB Auburn
31. Kenyon Green OL Texas A&M
32. George Pickens WR Georgia
33. Jahan Dotson WR Penn State
34. Logan Hall Dline Houston
35. Arnold Ebiketie EDGE Penn State
36. Kinglsey Enagbare EDGE South Carolina
37. S Jaquan Brisker Penn State
38. Zion Johnson OL BC
39. Trevor Panning OL Northern Iowa
40. Daniel Falaale OL Minnesota
41. WR Christian Watson
42. QB Matt Corral
43. QB Desmond Ridder
44. Jalen Pitre S Baylor
45. Tyler Smith OL Tulsa
46. Rasheed Walker OT Penn State
47. Sam Howell QB UNC
48. DeMarvin Leal Dline Texas A&M
49. Kenneth Walker RB Michigan State
50. Breece Hall RB Iowa State
51. Kaiir Elam CB Florida
52. Darian Kennard OL Kentucky
53. Trey McBride TE Colorado State
54. Skyy Moore WR Western Michigan
55. Kyler Gordon CB Washington
56. Kerby Joseph S Illinois
57. Drake Jackson EDGE USC
58. Myaji Sanders EDGE Cincinnati
59. Quay Walker LB Georgia
60. Christian Harris LB Alabama
61. Chad Muma LB Wyoming
62. Troy Anderson LB Montana State
63. Cameron Thomas DL San Diego State
64. Dylan Parham OL Memphis
65. Isiah Spiller RB Clemson
66. Leo Chanal LB Wisconsin
67. Calvin Austin III WR Memphis
68. Jalen Tolbert WR South Alabama
69. Chris Paul OL Tulsa
70. Cole Strange OL Chattanooga
71. Max Mitchell OL San Diego State
72. Phidarian Mathis DL Alabama
73. Bryan Cook S Cincinnati
74. John Metchie WR Alabama
75. Nick Cross S Maryland
76. Perrio Winfrey Dline Oklahoma
77. David Ojabo EDGE Michigan
78. Nik Bonnito EDGE Oklahoma
79. Jeremy Ruckert TE Ohio State
80. Sam Williams EDGE Ole Miss
81. Marcus Jones CB Houston
82. Travis Jones DL UCONN
83. Martin Emerson CB Miss State
84. Brian Asomoah LB Oklahoma
85. Josh Jobe CB Alabama
86. Nicholas Petit Frere OL Ohio State
87. Cordale Flott S LSU
88. Channing Tindall LB Georgia
89. Dononvahn West OL Arizona State
90. Greg Dulcich TE UCLA
91. Tariq Woolen CB UTSA
92. Wandale Robinson WR Kentucky
93. Charlie Kolar TE Iowa State
94. Kyren Willaims RB Notre Dame
95. Micah McFadden LB Indiana
96. Carson Strong QB Nevada
97. Justyn Ross WR Clemson
98. Damone Clark LB LSU
99. Isiah Likely TE Cincinnati
100. Velus Jones WR Tennessee
 
Last edited:
Here is my big board so there is no question the order of talent I see

1. Aidan Hutchinson EDGE Michigan
2. Kayvon Thibodeaux EDGE Oregon
3. Ahmad Gardner CB Cincinnati
4. Evan Neal OT Alabama
5. Kyle Hamilton S Notre Dame
6. CB Derek Stingley LSU
7. Travon Walker EDGE Georgia
8. Charles Cross OT Mississippi State
9. Tyler Linderbaum OT Iowa State
10. Ikem Ekwonu OT NC State
11. Jameson Willaims WR Alabama
12. Nakobe Dean ILB Georgia
13. Garret Wilson WR Ohio State
14. Drake London WR USC
15. Devin Lloyd ILB Utah
16. QB Malik Willis Liberty
17. QB Kenny Pickett Pittsburgh
18. Treylon Burks WR Arkansas
19. Jordan Davis DT Georgia
20. Jermaine Johnson EDGE Florida State
21. Daxton Hill S Michigan
22. George Karlaftis EDGE Purdue
23. Bernhard Raimman OT CMU
24. Trent McDuffie CB Washington
25. Andrew Booth Jr CB Clemson
26. Boye Mafe EDGE Minnesota
27. Chris Olave WR Ohio State
28. Lewis Cine S Georgia
29. Devonte Wyatt Dline Georgia
30. Roger McCreary CB Auburn
31. Kenyon Green OL Texas A&M
32. George Pickens WR Georgia
33. Jahan Dotson WR Penn State
34. Logan Hall Dline Houston
35. Arnold Ebiketie EDGE Penn State
36. Kinglsey Enagbare EDGE South Carolina
37. S Jaquan Brisker Penn State
38. Zion Johnson OL BC
39. Trevor Panning OL Northern Iowa
40. Daniel Falaale OL Minnesota
41. WR Christian Watson
42. QB Matt Corral
43. QB Desmond Ridder
44. Jalen Pitre S Baylor
45. Tyler Smith OL Tulsa
46. Rasheed Walker OT Penn State
47. Sam Howell QB UNC
48. DeMarvin Leal Dline Texas A&M
49. Kenneth Walker RB Michigan State
50. Breece Hall RB Iowa State
51. Kaiir Elam CB Florida
52. Darian Kennard OL Kentucky
53. Trey McBride TE Colorado State
54. Skyy Moore WR Western Michigan
55. Kyler Gordon CB Washington
56. Kerby Joseph S Illinois
57. Drake Jackson EDGE USC
58. Myaji Sanders EDGE Cincinnati
59. Quay Walker LB Georgia
60. Christian Harris LB Alabama
61. Chad Muma LB Wyoming
62. Troy Anderson LB Montana State
63. Cameron Thomas DL San Diego State
64. Dylan Parham OL Memphis
65. Isiah Spiller RB Clemson
66. Leo Chanal LB Wisconsin
67. Calvin Austin III WR Memphis
68. Jalen Tolbert WR South Alabama
69. Chris Paul OL Tulsa
70. Cole Strange OL Chattanooga
71. Max Mitchell OL San Diego State
72. Phidarian Mathis DL Alabama
73. Bryan Cook S Cincinnati
74. John Metchie WR Alabama
75. Nick Cross S Maryland
76. Perrio Winfrey Dline Oklahoma
77. David Ojabo EDGE Michigan
78. Nik Bonnito EDGE Oklahoma
79. Jeremy Ruckert TE Ohio State
80. Sam Williams EDGE Ole Miss
81. Marcus Jones CB Houston
82. Travis Jones DL UCONN
83. Martin Emerson CB Miss State
84. Brian Asomoah LB Oklahoma
85. Josh Jobe CB Alabama
86. Nicholas Petit Frere OL Ohio State
87. Cordale Flott S LSU
88. Channing Tindall LB Georgia
89. Dononvahn West OL Arizona State
90. Greg Dulcich TE UCLA
91. Tariq Woolen CB UTSA
92. Wandale Robinson WR Kentucky
93. Charlie Kolar TE Iowa State
94. Kyren Willaims RB Notre Dame
95. Micah McFadden LB Indiana
96. Carson Strong QB Nevada
97. Justyn Ross WR Clemson
98. Damone Clark LB LSU
99. Isiah Likely TE Cincinnati
100. Velus Jones WR Tennessee

so in your view, if the Lions take Willis #2, it will be a bad pick
 
so in your view, if the Lions take Willis #2, it will be a bad pick

I don't think they will but it would make sense given the QB future need. With reasoning even 16th best is fine. There are a handful of prospects if there is reasoning where it would be ok to do such as thing. QB is one of those positions. Prefer a trade down obviously. But if Willis becomes a superstar we won't care if he was a "reach" at 2 either
 
Last edited:
Think its Thibodeaux at 2 or trade down. Walker could surprise but I like Thibodeaux better

Dotson, Watson or Pickens at 32 at WR

Cine, Brisker or Pitre at 34 at safety (but Cine might be gone)

Round 3 find a LB in Harris, Muma, Anderson, Chanal

Round 3 97 Isiah Likely TE or flier on Carson Strong if still there
 
KT Pickens and Cine would be a great draft.

Don?t understand the Pickens hype. I mean I get it, but then I don?t. Dude has been all hype with literally only a handful of good games in college. Good comparison as far as big receiver/production would be Nico Collins who went 3rd round 89th overall. And he didn?t have a major injury either.
 
Don?t understand the Pickens hype. I mean I get it, but then I don?t. Dude has been all hype with literally only a handful of good games in college. Good comparison as far as big receiver/production would be Nico Collins who went 3rd round 89th overall. And he didn?t have a major injury either.

Pickens ran a 4.47 official time.....but I don't see him play to that speed. He reminds me a lot of Chark, actually.

I think he is going to be drafted too high, IMO. I'd take him at the top of round 3.....but he won't be there. I'd rather have Skyy Moore or John Metchie
 
Back
Top