2012 ALL MLB Team

[tycobb420]

Just my 2 cents

1b-Prince
2b-Cano
3b-Cabrera (duh)
SS- Desmond
C-Posey
RF- Beltran
LF-Braun
CF-Wonderboy
DH-Encarncion
Bench- Andy Dirks
RHP- R.A. Dickey
LHP- Price
Setup-David Hernandez
Closer- Kimbrell (I refuse to name Tampa's closer)

 

[Mitchrapp]

Andy Dirks, lol.

 

[Mitchrapp]

And Dickey over JV, lmao. Even in the NL, Dickey isn't even close. JV's ERA+ is 20 points better.

 

[mjsb2]

Andy Dirks, lol.

And Dickey over JV, lmao. Even in the NL, Dickey isn't even close. JV's ERA+ is 20 points better.

These both sum up my thoughts.

 

[spockmaster]

These both sum up my thoughts.

same here.

 

[servinthed]

Funny.

 

[coulomb]

I have a hard time giving respect to knuckleballers, let alone giving them awards. I mean, they don't even know where the damn ball is going, really. They should be the most superstitious people in baseball, because its all luck. I also hated wakefield, dude could have pitched til he was 60, & the ball would have looked the same.

 

[byco42]

Careful, you might increase Ty's tension. Offer your version and risk what he's risking by naming a team.

 

[Mitchrapp]

Already did, JV. And I can't imagine how Dirks gets on a list, on any list. And I usually like Ty's threads, he has some great post and information I enjoy but man - Dirks? AJ over Dirks by a mile and a half.

 

[Thumb]

Already did, JV. And I can't imagine how Dirks gets on a list, on any list. And I usually like Ty's threads, he has some great post and information I enjoy but man - Dirks? AJ over Dirks by a mile and a half.

For that matter there are a dozen guys you could take as a bench player over even Ajax.

 

[Mitchrapp]

For that matter there are a dozen guys you could take as a bench player over even Ajax.

True but my point and I wasn't clear was that even another Tiger would take Dirks spot.

 

[kalinecountry]

1B Prince
2B Cano
3B Cabrera
SS Jeter - don't care, 216 hits.
LF Braun
CF trout
RF Stanton
C Posey
DH Butler
Bench Zobrist
RHP Verlander
LHP Price
Setup Pestano
CL Kimbrel

 

[Thumb]

True but my point and I wasn't clear was that even another Tiger would take Dirks spot.

No, you were clear.

I was just saying if you're going to pick a bench player, why would someone like Dirks qualify when you could have someone like Mauer.

 

[Mitchrapp]

No, you were clear.

I was just saying if you're going to pick a bench player, why would someone like Dirks qualify when you could have someone like Mauer.

I agree. In fact I'd pick a ton players before Dirks.

 

[Thumb]

Trout - CF
Jeter - SS
Fielder - 1B
Cabrera - 3B
Braun* - LF
Cano- 2B
Rios - RF
Posey - C
DH - McCutchen

Bench Hamilton

RHP Verlander
LHP Price
CP Rodney

 

[byco42]

1b Fielder
2b Cano
SS Jeter
3b Cabrera
LF Braun
CF Trout
RF Craig
C Posey
LHP Kershaw
RHP Verlander
DH: Encarnacion
Bench: D.J. LeMahieu (bite me I knew him as a teenager when he played Bantam AA hockey with my kid in 2001-2002, and I picked a true bench player rather than a snubbed starter)
Closer: Kimbrel

 

[grandy]

C - Posey
1B - Fielder
2B - Cano
3B - Cabrera
SS - Zobrist
LF - Prado
CF - Trout
RF - Heyward

BE - Encarnacion
BE - McCutchen
BE - Headley

SP1 - Verlander
SP2 - Hernandez
SP3 - Kershaw

SU - Sean Burnett
CL - Kimbrel

Left off DH on purpose

 

[tonyballs]

For that matter there are a dozen guys you could take as a bench player over even Ajax.

Hamilton, Jeter. The list is endless...

 

[tycobb420]

Hamilton, Jeter. The list is endless...

Hamilton, Jeter etc are starters...I was looking for a part time player. I gave Dirks some love.

 

[byco42]

Hamilton, Jeter etc are starters...I was looking for a part time player. I gave Dirks some love.

I get you, Ty. Even if no one else does.