Iglesias gets hurt again. Rondon stuff to nasty to ignore and Soria's inconsistency early leaves him as setup man. McCann is our best option as Avila battles concussion and back issues. Gose hits well enough and solidifies CF defensively which limits playing time for Davis. McCann will hit better than Avila and Gose proves to be the answer in CF while causing havoc on the base paths.
There have been 28 MLB Catchers that have had 450 PAs Away over the last three years. Here is how their MLB Away OPS compares to their minors.
B. Posey .918 OPS vs .969 OPS -51
J. Lucroy .844 OPS vs .838 OPS +6
J. Mauer .825 OPS vs .833 OPS -8
C. Santana .815 OPS vs .900 OPS -85
C. Iannetta .806 OPS vs .931 OPS -125
Y. Molina .804 OPS vs .711 OPS
+93
C. Ruiz .792 OPS vs .752 OPS
+40
Y. Gomes .777 OPS vs .830 OPS -53
J. Jaso .774 OPS vs .816 OPS -42
R. Martin .745 OPS vs .810 OPS -65
M. Wieters .743 OPS vs 1.014 OPS -271
A.J. Ellis .742 OPS vs .785 OPS -43
M. Montero .735 OPS vs .826 OPS -91
R. Doumit .732 OPS vs .815 OPS -83
S. Perez .731 OPS vs .726 OPS +5
D. Mesoraco .725 OPS vs .794 OPS -69
W. Castillo .710 OPS vs .764 OPS -54
J. Saltalamacchia .705 OPS vs .823 OPS -118
W. Rosario .687 OPS vs .765 OPS -78
A. Avila .684 OPS vs .793 OPS -109
J. Castro .681 OPS vs .804 OPS -123
J. Buck .680 OPS vs .774 OPS -94
A.J. Pierzynski .676 OPS vs .737 OPS -61
B. McCann .675 OPS vs .812 OPS -137
D. Norris .656 OPS vs .858 OPS -202
K. Suzuki .650 OPS vs .804 OPS -154
T. Flowers .598 OPS vs .876 OPS -278
J.P. Arencibia .592 OPS vs .830 OPS -238
Not a single one of these MLB catchers had an OPS under .700 in the minors.
23 of the 28 had a minor league OPS of .765 or greater. The two lowest (Y. Molina and S. Perez) made it to the majors at age 21.
Tigers Catchers Minor League OPS
G. Greiner .839 OPS (only 1 season)
A. Avila .793 OPS
A. Greene .726 OPS
J. McCann .692 OPS
M. Pina .683
B. Holaday .662 OPS
M. Gonzalez .658 OPS
This same comparison/predictor could be used for other positions as well. Here are the other DET Tigers Minor League OPS.
J.D. Martinez .942 OPS
V. Martinez .881 OPS
D. Travis .876 OPS
I. Kinsler .868 OPS
J. Lennerton .809 OPS
N. Castellanos .804 OPS
A. Avila .793 OPS
T. Collins .790 OPS
W. Adames .786 OPS
R. Davis .784 OPS
D. Leyba .783 OPS
M. Cabrera .782 OPS (MLB at 20)
W. Bernard .780 OPS
E. Suarez .777 OPS
S. Moya .739 OPS
J. Wilson .736 OPS
J. Krizan .731 OPS
A. Westlake .722 OPS
A. Romine .721 OPS
D. Fields .698 OPS
J. Marte .696 OPS
X. Avery .694 OPS
H. Perez .660 OPS
J. Iglesias .638 OPS
A. Gose .633 OPS
D. Machado .622 OPS
Bold are all the minor league hitters we have traded since July of last year. All four are middle infielders. Glad we kept Perez, Iglesias and Machado. Where are most of the Tiger starters? Above .765 OPS.
Bottom line. Rarely, depending on age, do you see a MLB player excel if his Minor League OPS was under .700 (under .750 for corner fielders). Most are given a shot if they are a defensive whiz. However, you can only endure so many season of Rey Ordonez offense with Rey Ordonez defense.
If both Anthony Gose and Jose Iglesias perform according to their minor league numbers suggest and they are the starters, gawd help the offense. Then the suggestion is that James McCann will take over as a starter. More than a tad optimistic.
P. Fielder = .921 OPS
C. Shelton = .896 OPS
C. Granderson = .875 OPS
C. Maybin = .867 OPS
R. Raburn = .850 OPS
M. Thames = .840 OPS
B. Higginson = .834 OPS
S. Sizemore = .831 OPS
M. Joyce = .827 OPS
C. Wells = .816 OPS
B. Boesch = .796 OPS
C. Monroe = .782 OPS
C. Guillen = .778 OPS
A. Dirks = .778 OPS
A. Jackson = .763 OPS
A. Torres = .761 OPS
B. Pena = .756 OPS
J. Peralta = .753 OPS
B. Inge = .753 OPS
M. Tuiasosopo = .753 OPS
T. Hunter = .751 OPS
Wilkin Ramirez = .748 OPS
D. Kelly = .746 OPS
C. Thomas = .744 OPS
Avisail Garcia = .736 OPS
D. Ryan = .726 OPS
W. Rhymes = .725 OPS
R. Santiago = .689 OPS
O. Infante = .679 OPS (most before 21)
D. Worth = .673 OPS
M. Rabelo = .671 OPS
M. St. Pierre = .671 OPS
N. Logan = .660 OPS
For some of you. There is a reason that other teams take high OPS position players in trade. They have a greater rate of success. No they are not guaranteed success, just a greater rate. Conversely, rarely do you see a MLB starting position player with a minor league OPS under .700 (.750 for corners). Does it happen? Yes, but rarely and usually at a real young age (before 22).