Who should the Lions draft at #5?

[kdp80]

Espn poll says OT Eric Fisher, by a landslide

http://www.mlive.com/lions/index.ss...(Saginaw+Sports+-+MLive.com)&utm_content=ESPN

 

[cheeno]

Espn poll says OT Eric Fisher, by a landslide

http://www.mlive.com/lions/index.ss...(Saginaw+Sports+-+MLive.com)&utm_content=ESPN

Can't argue.

 

[Diggler Cometh]

It makes too much sense

 

[Monster]

If one of the LTs are there, u take him instantly. If not, Ansah.

 

[cheeno]

It makes too much sense

That's why it'll never happen.

 

[elrod817]

All wrong. The correct choice is cheeno Pfeiffer.

 

[Mitchrapp]

That's why it'll never happen.

This is the 5 pick, not the 2nd round pick. Mayhew can pick the early no brainer picks. Its after that he has trouble with.

 

[boogerlovejoy]

Milliner or Fisher.....in that order.

Either one and I'm a happy Lion fan.

 

[cheeno]

All wrong. The correct choice is cheeno Pfeiffer.

That pic will haunt me til the end of my days. Too bad she left me for the Krispy Kreme guy.

 

[mhughes0021]

Ive seen a lot of mocks with Fisher over Joeckel at 1. I dont see either of them falling to us but so far my rd 1 wish list is:

1 Joeckel
2 Fisher
3 Ansah
4 Milliner
5 Trade down

I want to finish the defense badly but getting the chance at a stud LT doesnt come along very often. The value there is just too good to pass up over taking a project DE. LT is no brainer.

A good topic for discussion is at what point would you guys want to trade down. Say the scenerio is the bills want to move up to get geno smith and theyre tossing in their 2nd round pick. At what point with whos left on the board do you make that deal?

 

[Mitchrapp]

All wrong. The correct choice is cheeno Pfeiffer.

Do I get some royalties out of this?

 

[Mitchrapp]

Ive seen a lot of mocks with Fisher over Joeckel at 1. I dont see either of them falling to us but so far my rd 1 wish list is:

1 Joeckel
2 Fisher
3 Ansah
4 Milliner
5 Trade down

I want to finish the defense badly but getting the chance at a stud LT doesnt come along very often. The value there is just too good to pass up over taking a project DE. LT is no brainer.

A good topic for discussion is at what point would you guys want to trade down. Say the scenerio is the bills want to move up to get geno smith and theyre tossing in their 2nd round pick. At what point with whos left on the board do you make that deal?

Maybe you can answer this because I don't know. What kind of stud is he compared to past LT studs?

 

[cheeno]

Ive seen a lot of mocks with Fisher over Joeckel at 1. I dont see either of them falling to us but so far my rd 1 wish list is:

1 Joeckel
2 Fisher
3 Ansah
4 Milliner
5 Trade down

I want to finish the defense badly but getting the chance at a stud LT doesnt come along very often. The value there is just too good to pass up over taking a project DE. LT is no brainer.

A good topic for discussion is at what point would you guys want to trade down. Say the scenerio is the bills want to move up to get geno smith and theyre tossing in their 2nd round pick. At what point with whos left on the board do you make that deal?

All those guys could be on the board and I would still take the deal, little to no difference in those picks and what you can grab with the Bills pick. You still get to grab possibly Johnson, Warmack, or Cooper for the oline, Jordan or Mingo or Star on the dline, or Rhodes at cb. Who knows Ansah could fall into your lap too.

 

[Monster]

Maybe it's just me, but I don't think Millner is really that great. I'd pass on him. I'd take Xavier Rhodes over him, in fact. Wouldn't take him at 5, but I would prefer him over Millner if we're going CB.

 

[elrod817]

Do I get some royalties out of this?

Yes you do. Checks are coming from tsmith.

 

[Mitchrapp]

Lol.

 

[cheeno]

It's in the mail.

 

[Diggler Cometh]

Maybe it's just me, but I don't think Millner is really that great. I'd pass on him. I'd take Xavier Rhodes over him, in fact. Wouldn't take him at 5, but I would prefer him over Millner if we're going CB.

Too stiff. Rhodes IMO would end up a safety

 

[mhughes0021]

Maybe you can answer this because I don't know. What kind of stud is he compared to past LT studs?

Joeckel not sure who he is compared to....maybe a jake long type cause of his athletisicm. Fisher is compared to Joe Staley. Either one would be day 1 starter at LT for next 10 years. (except for the lions who will play him at fullback for a couple years)

threw that in there just in case tony reads this thread lol

 

[Diggler Cometh]

Maybe you can answer this because I don't know. What kind of stud is he compared to past LT studs?

I see Nate solder.