Welcome to Detroit Sports Forum!

By joining our community, you'll be able to connect with fellow fans that live and breathe Detroit sports just like you!

Get Started
  • If you are no longer able to access your account since our recent switch from vBulletin to XenForo, you may need to reset your password via email. If you no longer have access to the email attached to your account, please fill out our contact form and we will assist you ASAP. Thanks for your continued support of DSF.

Tigers vs. guardians ALDS - Best of Five Games - October 5 to October 12

WATERCOOLER WEDNESDAY.
Totally Tigers

Have y’all recovered from Monday’s playoff game yet?
We’re continuing the fun today as we ask you to measure your observations and emotions about the Tigers in the playoffs.
This current team is nothing like we’ve ever seen before. Young, energetic, positive and closely-knit. Increasingly so, the number of home-grown players is growing.

Not a single free agent sits on this division series playoff roster. The total salaries add up to $18.6 mill. The 3 most-expensive players, Javy Baez, Miguel Cabrera ($8 mill buyout) and Kenta Maeda aren’t on the roster.
In contrast, the 2014 Tigers – the last time the team made the playoffs – had MLB’s 4th largest payroll at just under $189 mill. Only a handful of players were home-grown. Approximately one dozen of them were free agent signings by Detroit. More than half their roster were age 30 years or older.

The current team is known for their ability to have a different player be the difference maker every night. You never know how they are going to win the game. Their bullpen and overall pitching is superb and their defense (parts of it) are elite. But offense is still a challenge for them.

They also have the best pitcher in baseball who is expected to win the Cy Young. And A. J. Hinch is in the running for Manager of the Year. Scott Harris is also a candidate for Executive of the Year.

The 2014 team had a stellar rotation and could hit HRs. But they were slow, defensively-challenged and had one of MLB’s worst bullpens. They won only 4 more games than this year’s Tigers. No Tigers that year won any awards.
The team of a decade ago was swept by the Orioles in 3 games. The 2024 team is currently tied with the Guardians in the same division series.

Let’s now look back at this year’s games and also the team from 2014.
Which one of these teams was most exciting for you to watch? Who played more thrilling games?
Which Tiger team is the most exciting to watch?

1. The 2014 team.

2. The 2024 team.

3. Both teams equally exciting.

VOTE
 
WATERCOOLER WEDNESDAY.
Totally Tigers

Have y’all recovered from Monday’s playoff game yet?
We’re continuing the fun today as we ask you to measure your observations and emotions about the Tigers in the playoffs.
This current team is nothing like we’ve ever seen before. Young, energetic, positive and closely-knit. Increasingly so, the number of home-grown players is growing.

Not a single free agent sits on this division series playoff roster. The total salaries add up to $18.6 mill. The 3 most-expensive players, Javy Baez, Miguel Cabrera ($8 mill buyout) and Kenta Maeda aren’t on the roster.
In contrast, the 2014 Tigers – the last time the team made the playoffs – had MLB’s 4th largest payroll at just under $189 mill. Only a handful of players were home-grown. Approximately one dozen of them were free agent signings by Detroit. More than half their roster were age 30 years or older.

The current team is known for their ability to have a different player be the difference maker every night. You never know how they are going to win the game. Their bullpen and overall pitching is superb and their defense (parts of it) are elite. But offense is still a challenge for them.

They also have the best pitcher in baseball who is expected to win the Cy Young. And A. J. Hinch is in the running for Manager of the Year. Scott Harris is also a candidate for Executive of the Year.

The 2014 team had a stellar rotation and could hit HRs. But they were slow, defensively-challenged and had one of MLB’s worst bullpens. They won only 4 more games than this year’s Tigers. No Tigers that year won any awards.
The team of a decade ago was swept by the Orioles in 3 games. The 2024 team is currently tied with the Guardians in the same division series.

Let’s now look back at this year’s games and also the team from 2014.
Which one of these teams was most exciting for you to watch? Who played more thrilling games?
Which Tiger team is the most exciting to watch?

1. The 2014 team.

2. The 2024 team.

3. Both teams equally exciting.

VOTE
that is certainly a loaded question that steers the reader into answering how she wants them to answer. People are a prisoner of the moment, and over the past 6 weeks or so, this team has certainly been "exciting and thrilling." But overall, that 2014 team was more fun to watch, and certainly the better team. Remember, if they hadn't expanded the playoffs, this team wouldn't have even been a playoff team.
 
that is certainly a loaded question that steers the reader into answering how she wants them to answer. People are a prisoner of the moment, and over the past 6 weeks or so, this team has certainly been "exciting and thrilling." But overall, that 2014 team was more fun to watch, and certainly the better team. Remember, if they hadn't expanded the playoffs, this team wouldn't have even been a playoff team.
About the extending the playoff teams if they hadn’t maybe Detroit plays Chicago differently those last two games. One win, with a possible Skubal is all what was needed.
 
About the extending the playoff teams if they hadn’t maybe Detroit plays Chicago differently those last two games. One win, with a possible Skubal is all what was needed.
good point. I thought in 2014 there was only 1 wild card, but they have had 2 since 2012.
 
Tigers name surprise starter for ALDS Game 3 in hopes of taking upper hand.
MCBTB

How Keider Montero went from being off Tigers' playoff roster to starting Game 3 of ALDS.
Freep
 
FAN FEEDBACK: DIVISION SERIES GAME #3.
Totally Tigers



Wow. Again.
Haven’t these been absolutely incredible games?
The Detroit Tigers took the lead on Wednesday, winning 3-0 and going up on the Guardians 2-1 in the series.
And once again, there were many heroes. Pitchers, relievers, hitters and defensive players. And also those who don’t take the field.
As such, it would be impossible to highlight just 1 play of the day. Which is why I ask you to think back over these past 3 games plus the 2 contests with the Houston Astros.
Here is your challenge: Pick just one player you feel has contributed the most to these 4 game wins.
Just one. Your own personal MVP.
Tell us who he is and why you selected him in 3 sentences. Of course, we encourage you to respond to other readers’ comments as well.
 
Tigers-Guardians will play their elimination game at 1:08 ET Saturday instead of prime time. Sounds like there were weather concerns for late in the evening.
 
Tigers-Guardians ALDS Game 5 time moved up to 1 p.m. ET due to weather.
Tigers official site

Tigers-Guardians ALDS Game 5 start time changed due to expected inclement weather.
The final game of the 2024 American League Divisional Series will start at 1:08 p.m. ET instead of 8:08 p.m. ET.
BYBTB

Saturday's Tigers-Guardians Game 5 start time move up.
Detnews

Detroit Tigers' Game 5 showdown with Cleveland Guardians moved to 1:08 p.m.
Freep
 
Back
Top