The decision to lift Verlander with two outs in the ninth inning was made solely by manager Brad Ausmus, a decision he referred to as a "no brainer" on Friday night.
For 8 2/3 innings, Verlander dominated the Kansas City Royals, giving up just four base hits and one run. He entered the ninth inning with 100 pitches under his belt and retired his first two batters, needing only eight pitches to do so.
But Verlander's stellar start came to an abrupt end when he gave up a broken-bat single to Eric Hosmer with his 114th pitch. With Royals catcher Salvador Perez due up, Ausmus decided Verlander's night was over and called on reliever Alex Wilson.
The reason?
"(Verlander) was at 115 pitches, Perez has hit .450 off him over the course of 40 plate appearances and he's got nine extra-base hits," Ausmus said Friday. "The last three guys barreled the ball up on Verlander. I thought it was a no-brainer."
But the "no-brainer" move proved costly.
Perez deposited the second pitch he saw from Wilson into the Tigers' bullpen to tie the game at 3-all, and ultimately force extra innings. Wilson was eventually bailed out when rookie Dixon Machado hit a walk-off single in the 12th inning. But it was Ausmus' decision to lift Verlander that was the biggest talking point after the game.
"Obviously the fans wanted me to stay in. I wanted to stay in. But that's the manager's call," Verlander said. "Hindsight being 20-20, it didn't work out the way I'm sure Brad would've liked. It was probably the worst-case scenario. But I think you look at the big overall picture. Salvador's somebody that's had some success against me."
Did Ausmus consider bringing in any other relievers to face Perez? Perhaps left-handed reliever Blaine Hardy?
"Why, because of the reverse splits? That actually happened earlier in the year, where Wilson got the save, and I said at that time, and I'll say it again -- I understand the reverse splits, and if I had a lefty in there, I might leave him in there to face Perez," Ausmus said. "But I'm not bringing in a lefty to face Perez with the game on the line."
The decision to lift Verlander, who was just one out recording his second complete game this season, didn't sit well with the 32,926 fans in attendance at Comerica Park. Ausmus was showered with boos as he made his way back to the dugout.
"That's his decision. He's the manager," Verlander said. "Like I said, I always want the ball, so it's up to the manager to take me out. It was that way with (former manager Jim Leyland), and it's that way with Brad. If I've ever got the decision, I want to stay in. Those guys know that, and that's their decision to make."
http://www.mlive.com/tigers/index.ssf/2015/09/detroit_tigers_manager_brad_au_21.html