2006 (WS Appearance)
Pitching 1st
Offense 2nd
Defense 2nd
Base Running 7th
2011
Pitching 7th
Offense 7th
Defense 8th
Base Running 14th
2012 (WS Appearance)
Pitching 6th
Offense 6th
Defense 13th
Base Running 13th
2013
Pitching 2nd
Offense 3rd
Defense 10th
Base Running 15th
2014
Pitching 9th
Offense 2nd
Defense 13th
Base Running 14th
2015
Pitching 15th
Offense 2nd
Defense 4th
Base Running 15th
2016
Pitching 6th
Offense 3rd
Defense 13th
Base Running 14th
2017
Pitching 14th
Offense 14th
Defense 12th
Base Running 15th
Defense and Base Running are huge in the playoffs. Except for 2006, DET has been one of the worst in the AL in both areas. Add to the fact our catchers have been consistently near the bottom at pitch framing and you wonder how the pitcher survived. Bad defense. Bad pitch framing. Bad Bull pen. If I were a DET starter, I would want to get the heck out of town.
The offense looks good. Until they get picked off on a dumb mistake or those constant GIDP. It is like the team that boasts being able to get into the red zone, but when they do, they get the crucial holding or personal foul pushing them back out to the 35 or 40. The offense racks up their stats while piling on, but has difficulty scratching out a key run late in a game. It is all smoke and mirrors.