Calvin Johnson #3

[beez]

LOOOOOOL!!! Beez...Thas ma quarterback!

Hey I know I get my lumps for it but I always have the stats to back it up...you guys just use opinions and a few plays a year to argue against it. Phillip Rivers is praised but he plays in a shit division and has almost the exact numbers as Romo over their careers. He just doesn't play for Dallas.

 

[mhughes0021]

Hey I know I get my lumps for it but I always have the stats to back it up...you guys just use opinions and a few plays a year to argue against it. Phillip Rivers is praised but he plays in a shit division and has almost the exact numbers as Romo over their careers. He just doesn't play for Dallas.

ummmm, thats what the list is.....OPINIONS! The opinion of the NFL players is Cam is better than Romo.....and they are right.

Now i dont agree with their opinion that Cam is better than Staff but alot of analysts feel the same way cause cam had 1 good year out of 1. Staff has had 1 good year out of many. Now if it was truly based on last years performance ONLY than Staffs year should have put him in the top 10 easily. But we all know that eventhought they say that its based on only last year....that people vote mainly on your career (rivers for example).

 

[beez]

ummmm, thats what the list is.....OPINIONS! The opinion of the NFL players is Cam is better than Romo.....and they are right.

Now i dont agree with their opinion that Cam is better than Staff but alot of analysts feel the same way cause cam had 1 good year out of 1. Staff has had 1 good year out of many. Now if it was truly based on last years performance ONLY than Staffs year should have put him in the top 10 easily. But we all know that eventhought they say that its based on only last year....that people vote mainly on your career (rivers for example).

Which is why the list is trash...now you're getting it. Cam and Patrick Peterson are praised for good years last year. Rivers is praised for a career... Vick is praised for a half of a good season 2 years ago..Arian Foster isn't a top 5 rb and Chris Johnson is #100...there is no consistency with how the list is even voted on, let alone having the right players in the right spots..it's trash. Just take the Calvin Johnson comliment and move on.

 

[beez]

And opinions should be based off of stats I would think... the player could say Troy Smith is better than Ben Roethlisberger but that wouldn't make much snese considering their years last season would it?

 

[wheels002]

Not to ention that I think Peyton was 50 and he didnt even fucking play a snap.