WalterFootball 2016 NFL Free Agent Signing Grades.
Lions re-sign DT Haloti Ngata (2 years, $12M; $6M guaranteed): C+ Grade
Detroit's acquisition of Haloti Ngata was seen as a huge move by the Lions last offseason, but as usual, Ravens general manager Ozzie Newsome had the last laugh. Newsome sold the Lions a bit of a lemon, as Ngata wasn't anywhere near the player who dominated the line of scrimmage for Baltimore years ago. Ngata was still solid at stopping the run, but at 32, his pass-rushing skills have eroded.
The Lions have lost some veterans this offseason, so I can understand why they wouldn't want to see another depart. I'm fine with Detroit keeping Ngata, though the team is overpaying a bit for him. Brandon Mebane is a comparable player in terms of talent level, and he's getting slightly more overall and a bit less guaranteed on three years instead of two.
Lions sign WR Marvin Jones (5 years, $40M; $17M guaranteed): MILLEN "D" Grade
I'm giving the Lions a Millen for this, but unlike other Millen grades, this isn't an "F." I'm giving this a "D," but I just couldn't resist slapping the Lions with a Millen for spending major resources on an underwhelming wide receiver. That's the very origin of the Millen grade.
In all seriousness, this is a ton of money for a player who is nothing more than a No. 2 receiver. The Lions are paying Marvin Jones like a top wideout, but he's not one. He has never eclipsed 65 catches or more than 816 receiving yards in a single season. He also had A.J. Green drawing attention away from him. Teams will be able to focus more on him now, which will limit his production.
This signing reminds me a lot of the Eagles bringing in Byron Maxwell last spring. Maxwell, also a No. 2 on his former team, was given a ton of money because the Eagles were desperate at corner, and he happened to be the best player at the position available. That's exactly the case with Jones, as the free-agent receiver market is very weak. The Lions are overreacting to the Calvin Johnson retirement, and panicking in any market never ends well.
Lions re-sign DT Haloti Ngata (2 years, $12M; $6M guaranteed): C+ Grade
Detroit's acquisition of Haloti Ngata was seen as a huge move by the Lions last offseason, but as usual, Ravens general manager Ozzie Newsome had the last laugh. Newsome sold the Lions a bit of a lemon, as Ngata wasn't anywhere near the player who dominated the line of scrimmage for Baltimore years ago. Ngata was still solid at stopping the run, but at 32, his pass-rushing skills have eroded.
The Lions have lost some veterans this offseason, so I can understand why they wouldn't want to see another depart. I'm fine with Detroit keeping Ngata, though the team is overpaying a bit for him. Brandon Mebane is a comparable player in terms of talent level, and he's getting slightly more overall and a bit less guaranteed on three years instead of two.
Lions sign WR Marvin Jones (5 years, $40M; $17M guaranteed): MILLEN "D" Grade
I'm giving the Lions a Millen for this, but unlike other Millen grades, this isn't an "F." I'm giving this a "D," but I just couldn't resist slapping the Lions with a Millen for spending major resources on an underwhelming wide receiver. That's the very origin of the Millen grade.
In all seriousness, this is a ton of money for a player who is nothing more than a No. 2 receiver. The Lions are paying Marvin Jones like a top wideout, but he's not one. He has never eclipsed 65 catches or more than 816 receiving yards in a single season. He also had A.J. Green drawing attention away from him. Teams will be able to focus more on him now, which will limit his production.
This signing reminds me a lot of the Eagles bringing in Byron Maxwell last spring. Maxwell, also a No. 2 on his former team, was given a ton of money because the Eagles were desperate at corner, and he happened to be the best player at the position available. That's exactly the case with Jones, as the free-agent receiver market is very weak. The Lions are overreacting to the Calvin Johnson retirement, and panicking in any market never ends well.