By joining our community, you'll be able to connect with fellow fans that live and breathe Detroit sports just like you!
Get StartedTigers are frustrating with runners in scoring position with less than 2 outs.If Greene had just done what Witt just did last at-bat, we would be done with this game.
Dickerson said lifted for defenseThere must be a reason; AJ wouldn’t throw in a defensive replacement for one of our few hot hitters in a tie game.
If AJ actually lifted Carpenter for Kreidler without a better reason than defensive replacement with him coming up in the next inning in a tie game, we didn’t deserve to win this one. I hope he gets asked about it in the post-game interview.Cant win the. All. But this is another loss it feels I like we should have won.
I didn’t listen but tv broadcast thought he may have hurt something. They were not sure.If AJ actually lifted Carpenter for Kreidler without a better reason than defensive replacement with him coming up in the next inning in a tie game, we didn’t deserve to win this one. I hope he gets asked about it in the post-game interview.
If Carpenter has to sit for a while (sore hamstring alluded to post-game by Hinch), we won't have much to counter the Padres with. There simply isn't any depth on this team to counter all the injuries. The Padres have 6 guys hitting above .300 (4 of them over .340), and only one below .200 in the normal lineup.Tiger Mendoza hitters
Malloy .175
Keith .180
Kriedler .105
Batters close
Green .226
Sweeney .222
I guess it’s the same amount of guys at KC.
Because it has proven it doesn't work. Sure sometimes, but overall it fails. And don't forget the ML players these days don't know how to bunt, generally. Plus if the player was on 3rd, there is no guarantee Tork still hits a fly ball. Still a successful series.I know bunting is supposed to be to be bad. But ZM already has 3 hits. Why not have him lay one down and try to beat it out ? He can handle the bat. We tie game on Torks fly ball if AJ does this. I just don’t get why sacrificing down 1 run is bad.
Greene is back down to .226.
McKinstry does. Situation matters. The batter does matter. If it was a different batter like Tork, Greene, Torres, Baez, others I agree.Because it has proven it doesn't work. Sure sometimes, but overall it fails. And don't forget the ML players these days don't know how to bunt, generally. Plus if the player was on 3rd, there is no guarantee Tork still hits a fly ball. Still a successful series.
That's the point he already had 3 hits. Why would you want him to bunt? He has 6 sac bunts in 6 years. Not a ringing endorsement.McKinstry does. Situation matters. The batter does matter. If it was a different batter like Tork, Greene, Torres, Baez, others I agree.
ZM can bunt for a hit too.. win, win.
He already had 3 hits. Rolling dice for #4 is like hoping Greene will get out of his Homer slump or freaking hit a fly ball with a runner in third, and less than 2 outs lol. I told my wife no way McKinstry gets his 4th hit. (Law of averages right)
It was only a 1 run deficit. Gotta get that runner over.
I guarantee if this was a playoff game he would been bunting. Situations matter. The numbers may say you guys are right and I keep agreeing to switch my thinking to your ways but he foul pop out to third and failed to move runner over. Just not productive.
Maybe he had a great at bats today. But like Greene he failed to move the runner 90 feet when it counted…Frustrating. Like Bo blowing that dodger game. Colt blowing that Mariners game and today that makes 3 i am 90% sure we should have won.
Just a non productive at bat. But the way he's been playing I think I rather have him hit instead of giving himself up. Just didn't work out today is all.McKinstry does. Situation matters. The batter does matter. If it was a different batter like Tork, Greene, Torres, Baez, others I agree.
ZM can bunt for a hit too.. win, win.
He already had 3 hits. Rolling dice for #4 is like hoping Greene will get out of his Homer slump or freaking hit a fly ball with a runner in third, and less than 2 outs lol. I told my wife no way McKinstry gets his 4th hit. (Law of averages right)
It was only a 1 run deficit. Gotta get that runner over.
I guarantee if this was a playoff game he would been bunting. Situations matter. The numbers may say you guys are right and I keep agreeing to switch my thinking to your ways but he foul pop out to third and failed to move runner over. Just not productive.
Maybe he had a great at bats today. But like Greene he failed to move the runner 90 feet when it counted…Frustrating. Like Bo blowing that dodger game. Colt blowing that Mariners game and today that makes 3 i am 90% sure we should have won.
Water finds its level career .222 hitter. Already 3 hits. He isn’t getting a 4th. Im glad he is hitting this year so far. Get that runner over any way possible. Agree to disagree. At home. Play for the tie till you get a crack at winning it .. I think that makes us 0-2 in extras now.That's the point he already had 3 hits. Why would you want him to bunt? He has 6 sac bunts in 6 years. Not a
Founded in 2011, Detroit Sports Forum is a community of fanatics dedicated to teams like the Lions, Tigers, Pistons, Red Wings, Wolverines, and more. We live and breathe Detroit sports!