MichChamp02 said:If you're talking about a playoff for the FBS, it's totally irrelevent. There are a lot fewer teams. Here WSU had to win 3 regional games, and a semifinal to make the Championship. A playoff in the FBS wouldn't need that many games... just have the champs from every BCS conference play + 2 at large, (like Alabama and Boise St.). The question of whether or not anyone "deserves" it shouldn't even come up, except for maybe the Big Least champ.
this isn't really a Cinderella story though: WSU went 8-3, with 3 close losses, 1 in OT. They barely made the D-II playoffs, and all the teams they've beaten finished with either 1 or 2 losses, so it's not like "everybody" gets a shot. They were a good team.
Ok, I was just going off of Bob's word on the cindarella thing.
I agree with your format, except that I wouldn't include Alabama, because they didn't win their conference...