Retire #4

[beez]

Not what I meant. He made big kicks but at the end of the day, QB (right or wrong) get judged by SB. K's, don't. You could say "this guy was great because he made big kicks" but when do you ever hear "he is Hall worthy because he won a SB" when referring to a K? Or "this guy never won a SB, overrated and choked" when referring to a K?

fair enough.

 

[schles192]

Not what I meant. He made big kicks but at the end of the day, QB (right or wrong) get judged by SB. K's, don't. You could say "this guy was great because he made big kicks" but when do you ever hear "he is Hall worthy because he won a SB" when referring to a K? Or "this guy never won a SB, overrated and choked" when referring to a K?

There are only two kickers i can think of as choke artists:

Ray finkle,
Scott Norwood

 

[Mitchrapp]

There are only two kickers i can think of as choke artists:

Ray finkle,
Scott Norwood

True. Though if Norwood had made that kick I doubt anyone would remember him..It would have all been about Jim Kelley.

 

[beez]

There are only two kickers i can think of as choke artists:

Ray finkle,
Scott Norwood

Finkle gets a pass...it was that Damn Marino. Laces out man. Just another instance of a starting QB holding for a kick when he shouldn't have been.

 

[schles192]

"Dan Marino should die of gonorrhea and rot in hell" Mrs Finkle.