https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/pod-of-fame/id1521600567?i=1000523634900
Tigers Pod Of Fame Podcast: Episode 45: Lou Whitaker with Cody Stavenhagen. 48 minutes.
Jim is joined by Cody Stavenhagen, Detriot Tigers beat writer for The Athletic, to breakdown the hall of fame candidacy of former Tigers Second Baseman Lou Whitaker.
Jim and John first discuss how hard it is to talk about Whitaker without bringing up his double-play partner Alan Trammell, who recently was voted into Cooperstown in 2018 (6:38).
Next, they talk about the 1984 World Series, similarities between Whitaker and current HOF candidate Scott Rolen, and Whitaker's eye-popping WAR (10:31).
Finally, they discuss why Whitaker only won four gold gloves despite being one of the better defensive second basemen in history and how that impacts his candidacy (33:26), before coming to a conclusion on whether or not Whitaker deserves a plaque in Cooperstown (40:06).
Lou Whitaker's rWAR is higher than any eligible non tainted player not in the OF whose full career was since 1901, when the AL became a major league.
Every other player with a higher rWAR was either:
- not eligible yet.
- tainted (by PEDs or gambling).
- played before 1900.