Spartanmack
Senior Member
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2013
- Messages
- 17,531
I have been having so much fun following the two of you go back and forth on this riveting academic discourse that I couldn’t resist joining the merriment.
There is no universe in which characterizing any point in “late September” as being “well into the fall” makes sense, especially when the event - I guess we are talking about the acquisition of some worthless masks – may not have happened during the fall at all.
Let’s break this down a bit – remember, “30 days hath September.”
So “late September” should be characterized as being any time just after midnight the early morning of September 16 - the beginning of the second half- and just before midnight the night of September 30.
So let’s look at some of the facts.
The fall began this year, 2020, on September 22, at 9:30 AM EDST. We have to look at the date of the equinox, September 22, as being both part of the summer, and also as part of the fall, because until 9:30 AM it was indeed summer, and after that it was fall - nine days of fall in September.
Adding 31 days of fall in October, 30 days of fall in November, and 21 days of fall in December (the 21st being a partial day; fall ends at 5:02 AM EST) gives us a total of 91 days of fall in 2020.
So had the event in question – again I guess it was the purchase of some worthless masks - occurred after 9:30 AM on September 22 and before midnight on September 30, the event would have indeed happened in the fall, at some point between less than 1% of the way into fall and not quite 10% of the way into fall.
I don’t see how it is reasonable to characterize any point less than 1% of the way into something and not even as much as 10% of the way into that thing as being “well into” that thing.
Now, let’s go back and examine the possibility that the event - again, I guess it was the purchase of some worthless masks –in “late September” occurred at a point in time between after midnight the morning of September 16 and just before 9:30 AM on September 22 - if that were the case, the event wouldn’t have happened in the fall at all – it would have indeed happened during the summer.
It is in arguably erroneous to claim that an event that happened during the summer happened “well into the fall.”
This was a lot of fun guys, keep it up.
Hey, no fair. I wouldn’t want Gulo to feel left out by you not also over-analyzing his claim that masks were available in mid summer when he later said he bought them in late September. He has worked hard in all this and deserves equal time. Also, i don’t care about calendar technicalities, if it happens after week 3 of college football, it’s well into the fall as far as I’m concerned. So there is a universe where it makes sense. My universe. The only universe that counts.
Last edited: