Greatest RF since 1969

[Mitchrapp]

now you're being intentionally ridiculous. sometimes i feel like you argue just for the sake of arguing.

Back at you bub. You know Ty meant MLB career. Otherwise why not count that Japanese power hitter who hit over 700 home runs.

 

[tycobb420]

Reggie pulls out the victory.

 

[spockmaster]

Mitch[/color]]

now you're being intentionally ridiculous. sometimes i feel like you argue just for the sake of arguing.

Back at you bub. You know Ty meant MLB career. Otherwise why not count that Japanese power hitter who hit over 700 home runs.

i fail to see how saying that we shouldnt discount half his career is ridiculous, but whatever.

 

[Thumb]

Mitch[/color]]Can imagine what Pujols would do in japan. Maybe a 2000 OPS.

Maybe.

But Ichiro came from by your description, inferior talent pools, came to MLB and still dominated.

Doesn't matter what league he started in, Ichiro still put up the numbers, period.

 

[Mitchrapp]

Than Oh and his world breaking home run total should get in on one of these polls. No on is suggesting Ichiro is not a great player or not worthy to be a hall of famer but his Japanese totals don't count here in the MLB. They're seperate.