Best would have been a very good player if he did not have those concussions. No one really knew or focused at the time for how serious they were. Best kind of led the way in my mind. Mayhew kind of let the other GM's off the hook moving forward. You won't see many players with Best's history being drafted very high. So I can't really get on him for that pick.
Leshoure is or was a pot head and the reason for being in the dog house. He was suspended for 2 games which if I recall correctly means he would have been busted 3 times. Granted he tore his Achilles but as far as Mayhew being called out is kind of speculative. I guess you could question his analytical skills in choosing character guys but in this industry, who knows.
To me, the Best pick was the correct pick at the time. He was a difference maker when he played. Absolutely HAD to be accounted for.....especially in the short passing/screen game. True difference makers don't come around that often in the NFL, when you can get one.....sometimes you have to take the risk.
Lions needed a playmaker in the backfield at the time....Best fit the mold. To be honest, he still has had the 4th most productive career of any running back in that draft. SAD RB class in 2010.
1 9 Buffalo Bills C. J. Spiller Clemson
1 12 San Diego Chargers Ryan Mathews Fresno State
1 30 Detroit Lions Jahvid Best California
2 36 Kansas City Chiefs Dexter McCluster Ole Miss
2 51 Minnesota Vikings Toby Gerhart Stanford
2 58 Houston Texans Ben Tate Auburn
2 59 Cleveland Browns Montario Hardesty Tennessee
4 112 New York Jets Joe McKnight USC
6 173 San Francisco 49ers Anthony Dixon Mississippi State
6 180 Jacksonville Jaguars Deji Karim Southern Illinois
6 188 Pittsburgh Steelers Jonathan Dwyer Georgia Tech
6 193 Green Bay Packers James Starks Buffalo
6 200 Philadelphia Eagles Charles Scott LSU