Welcome to Detroit Sports Forum!

By joining our community, you'll be able to connect with fellow fans that live and breathe Detroit sports just like you!

Get Started
  • If you are no longer able to access your account since our recent switch from vBulletin to XenForo, you may need to reset your password via email. If you no longer have access to the email attached to your account, please fill out our contact form and we will assist you ASAP. Thanks for your continued support of DSF.

SI ranks all 32 starting QB's. Stafford ranked.......

What pace? Being an average NFL QB? I guess they better make room for guys like Dalton and Fitzpatrick also.
 
Stafford has 131 TDs through 6 seasons. Brees had 106 through 6.

Stafford=Marino

Hopefully Stafford wins some titles though. Detroit has a better team than most Miami teams.
 
Tell you what, when he starts looking like he can perform at half of Drew Brees's level, I'll agree with that. Until then, he's a nice mid-tier QB.
 
Stafford 131 TDs first 6 years. Missing 19 games
Brees 106 TDs first 6 years. Missing 22 games

Stafford start>Brees start
 
Don't 'cha know, TD passes get you into the HOF. Matt is as close to the HOF as I am..
 
Has there been a QB get into the HOF with an under .500 record and no playoff wins?
 
He's thrown the ball a lot, I get he "breaks records", but all this record breaking is simply related to quantity. He is terribly inefficient as a QB.

I don't think once I mentioned anything he sucks because he hasn't won a title. I think he is below average because he is very inaccurate, misses reads, panics under pressure, and is the most inconsistent QB in the league. He can look elite one game, and like he doesn't belong in the league the next.

I support my opinion/argument with facts and stats, just because you choose to ignore them doesn't make them invalid. You support yours with insults and Lions "records".

He's led some nice comebacks, but also allowed the other teams to comeback against the lions with some ill advised playing. He has nearly 2x the comebacks as Rodgers, does that mean in the 4th quarter you want Stafford of Rodgers? I would think not. To have a comeback once must be behind in the 4th quarter. So a guy like Stafford has a lot more chances for comebacks compared to the elite guys simply because he and his team aren't nearly as good in the 1st 3 quarters. Again a quantity thing.


Your "fact" is a weak QBR stat that nobody pays attention to. Good job. I know he's a good QB and I also know that he's not the guy holding them back.

And don't shit on the comebacks like you are. Of course Rodgers is the best in the game, but Stafford has ability as well. He's proven it numerous times.
 
Warner won the SB his first year. He was just older, quite the different path than Matt. And Moon, his NFL career started late. Figured you'd use those. I'll give you Brees, though if we're complaining about talent..ours blows those San Diego teams away..

Late bloomers, genius. You wanted some names, you got them. You'll give me Brees?? You're such a clown lol. And Warner was a Packer before he was a Ram, then he went to the Arena League. So NO, it really wasn't his 1st year.

You're wrong as usual.
 
Yes. Nonetheless, if Matt turns into Warren Moon..I'll be on board. Does anyone think he becomes Warren Moon?

Does anyone think Matt becomes a hof like the three players that were mentioned? It's been 6 years so far..anyone believes there's a chance he becomes a hof, even a 2% chance?

HOF?! WTF?! lol. Way to deflect the argument to a HOF discussion. Seek help..
 
Your "fact" is a weak QBR stat that nobody pays attention to. Good job. I know he's a good QB and I also know that he's not the guy holding them back.

And don't shit on the comebacks like you are. Of course Rodgers is the best in the game, but Stafford has ability as well. He's proven it numerous times.

It's not just QB rating, its anything you look at in terms of per attempt. He is incredibly inefficient. He does nothing at a high level besides throw a lot of passes.

But hey, it's easier to be on the hope he is good, because i want him to be good bandwagon train. You don't need anything to back it up. Just keep making statements and maybe someone will believe you eventually.

Also comebacks. Lets not forget those great Stafford comebacks. Like the one against the Bears last year. Down by four entering the forth. Leads us on two scoring drives. Lets look at his stats from those two heroic...give Stafford a comeback win stat drives...Ready here they are: 1/4 5 yards. Led us to 10 points. What a hero.
 
Let us not forget that he threw back to back INTs in the 2nd quarter. Instead of burying them early, Stafford got all Stafford and made some horrible decisions.
 
Let us not forget that he threw back to back INTs in the 2nd quarter. Instead of burying them early, Stafford got all Stafford and made some horrible decisions.

Ross fumble and special teams penalty on punt gave the Bears 14 points.

Stafford won that with ease despite the 2 ints.
 
Yeah he was wonderful. 22/39, 243 yards, 0 tds/2 int, 53.7 QBR. Just immaculate. WITH EASE BABY
 
Yeah he was wonderful. 22/39, 243 yards, 0 tds/2 int, 53.7 QBR. Just immaculate. WITH EASE BABY

243 reasons we won. Plus the deep ball drawing the PI. Bell and Bush should punch in some TDs every once in awhile. Finally a good run day for Stafford. Prater missed a FG.

23 true points on the road. Redzone mulligans. We won the game. Stafford gets kudos.
 
Back
Top