Welcome to Detroit Sports Forum!

By joining our community, you'll be able to connect with fellow fans that live and breathe Detroit sports just like you!

Get Started
  • If you are no longer able to access your account since our recent switch from vBulletin to XenForo, you may need to reset your password via email. If you no longer have access to the email attached to your account, please fill out our contact form and we will assist you ASAP. Thanks for your continued support of DSF.

The Colts dump Gosder

That's right. Also, we already established Dalton is the #7 QB based on Marvin Lewis Comments.

I wonder if A Rod is pissed that McCarthy hasn't come out and said he is the best in the NFL. If he does......how do we decide who is the best. I mean, if two coaches call their own, currently under contract, QB the best........how could we possibly decide who is better.....Aaron Rodgers or Joe Flacco???

What GM is going to call his own QB 32nd best??? That's my question.
 
He hasn't shit the bed. The game tape shows he is good, not shitting the bed.

11 wins. Monster numbers. A QB we can rely upon to move our offense (without a run game).

Stafford is on Marino TD pace. He's a first down machine. He's improving and he'll be in year 2 of the offense. Protect him and he'll have a big year.
 
I wonder if A Rod is pissed that McCarthy hasn't come out and said he is the best in the NFL. If he does......how do we decide who is the best. I mean, if two coaches call their own, currently under contract, QB the best........how could we possibly decide who is better.....Aaron Rodgers or Joe Flacco???

What GM is going to call his own QB 32nd best??? That's my question.

It'd be funny though.
 
Heard we picked up jerel worthy. Good job mayhew....finally figured out you can't draft so just start picking up ted thompsons trash and it still improves the team.
 
Last edited:
I wonder if A Rod is pissed that McCarthy hasn't come out and said he is the best in the NFL. If he does......how do we decide who is the best. I mean, if two coaches call their own, currently under contract, QB the best........how could we possibly decide who is better.....Aaron Rodgers or Joe Flacco???

What GM is going to call his own QB 32nd best??? That's my question.

This might be as close as we get. From the Bills GM:

PITTSFORD, N.Y. -- Buffalo Bills general manager Doug Whaley said Wednesday that the Bills are "almost in quarterback purgatory" because they do not have a franchise quarterback and are unlikely to pick near the top of the draft in coming years.

"Year 3, I would say, [Manuel] is a tad behind," Whaley said.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/1...ost-quarterback-purgatory-gm-doug-whaley-says
 
Gasp, a GM that's critical of their QB.

Instead, we get Mayhew coming out after 2014 saying Stafford had an "outstanding season."
 
Gasp, a GM that's critical of their QB.

Instead, we get Mayhew coming out after 2014 saying Stafford had an "outstanding season."

Stafford was outstanding.

Mayhew is knowledgable.
 
Gasp, a GM that's critical of their QB.

Instead, we get Mayhew coming out after 2014 saying Stafford had an "outstanding season."

I think he was just using the other definition of outstanding: still needing to be dealt with. From that perspective, he could be right. "Matthew's season was, and still is, outstanding. We will be forced to do something about his play soon."
 
They could extend him against next offseason. Can't wait.
 
That's some of the problem with Stafford IMO. He gets coddled so much by those around him. Would it be so blasphemous to say, "Stafford had a good season but he needs to get better"?
 
That's some of the problem with Stafford IMO. He gets coddled so much by those around him. Would it be so blasphemous to say, "Stafford had a good season but he needs to get better"?

Every QB needs to get better even after a good season. The problem is many are saying he didn't have a good season in 2013 or 2014. Those people are just blind haters.
 
That's some of the problem with Stafford IMO. He gets coddled so much by those around him. Would it be so blasphemous to say, "Stafford had a good season but he needs to get better"?

Mayhew has done exactly that before. After 2013 he was pretty critical of Stafford.

https://lockerdome.com/6265520638935361/6304468677439764

http://profootballtalk.nbcsports.co...laims-matthew-stafford-is-improving-steadily/

-----DEARBORN — Manny Ramirez was here during the bad days. Back when the Detroit Lions lost a lot. Back when they lost them all.

And he remembers what the locker room used to be like.

"Everyone would come in, do their job and bounce," said Ramirez, who originally played for the Lions from 2007-10. "Not really many players hung out together in the locker room and all that stuff."

And now?

"Now everyone wants to be together," the offensive lineman said. "Wants to be in the building, wants to work out every day. It's definitely different."

Case in point?

Quarterback Matthew Stafford took his offensive line to a recent Tigers game for some recent bonding time.

Stafford knows he needs to be better this year. Knows the offense needs to be better. But when asked what's the greatest challenge facing him personally this season, he cited the development of that offensive line.-----

Does that make you feel better?

Personally, I don't give a flying fuck about what GM's and coaches say in public about their current players. It's all coach speak.

Do ANY digging and you'll find everyone from Mayhew to Lombardi to Caldewell to Schwartz to Linehan to Stafford all saying he needs to do a better job of different aspects of his game. You can hate #9 all you want, to each his own, but your opinion on this subject is misinformed.
 
Last edited:
Did you read either of the two links you posted? The word outstanding was thrown around in the first. The second was Caldwell denying Stafford needs to be fixed.
 
Did you read either of the two links you posted? The word outstanding was thrown around in the first. The second was Caldwell denying Stafford needs to be fixed.

He doesn't need to be fixed. Everyone needs to improve but it's not a complete re-do on Stafford. He was a good QB in 2013 and outstanding in 2014. Not coach speak. Informed football minds talking about Stafford.
 
Did you read either of the two links you posted? The word outstanding was thrown around in the first. The second was Caldwell denying Stafford needs to be fixed.

He?s been doing well. He?s improving steadily. Things in this league don?t happen that way. No one makes a meteoric jump. It?s gradual, it?s too competitive. There are too many good players. And it?s a tough league, and I do think he?s making really good progress.?

If Caldwell doesn't think he needs to get better, why would he say he is improving......making progress??

Gotta take more out of what you're reading that JUST what you want to "hear".
 
My point is...if that is what you consider criticism you've got some pretty thin skin. Compared to other QBs of his level, Cutler, Newton, Romo even.
 
Hahaha. Did you say he's improving steadily?

images


Holy crap I needed a laugh tonight. Matt improved steadily, that was a good one.

200_s.gif
 
Back
Top