Welcome to Detroit Sports Forum!

By joining our community, you'll be able to connect with fellow fans that live and breathe Detroit sports just like you!

Get Started
  • If you are no longer able to access your account since our recent switch from vBulletin to XenForo, you may need to reset your password via email. If you no longer have access to the email attached to your account, please fill out our contact form and we will assist you ASAP. Thanks for your continued support of DSF.

Tigers 2024-2025 Offseason: Trades, Free Agents, Call ups, Rule 5, tender, non-tender, Awards

WATERCOOLER WEDNESDAY.
Totally Tigers

Yesterday’s blog was about the multiple rumors concerning Spencer Torkelson’s tenuous future with the Tigers and why it might make sense for the team to move on.

Torkelson just completed his 3rd year with the team however he’s been sent down to Toledo each of the last 2 years. There are concerns about both his defense and offense.
He had a couple promising months at the end of 2023 but noticeably regressed in 2024. The Tigers once again have mapped out a specific program for him to follow during this off-season.
So what do you think? Is it time to move on or should Tork be given a little longer leash?

Is it time for the Tigers to move on from Spencer Torkelson?

1. No, it's way too soon to make any decision about moving him.

2. Not just yet. He's still young and learning so give him a little more time to prove himself during the 2025 season.

3. Yes, he's had 3 years already and it's time to move on.

VOTE
I voted #2. He is still too young to move on from. He was better defensively last year and was one of their better hitters post all star break. I would give him one more year.
 
Tigers could have unique advantage if they want to explore Nolan Arenado trade.
MCBTB

Through the years, some of these stories I completely disagree with, but need to be posted so I don't look like
I am biased one way or another.
I agree with you. This would be a terrible idea. They got hot and snuck into the playoffs last year. They still have work to do to build the entire system. Trading away prospects for an aging 3B is not a good idea. That is a move you make if you think you are a player away. The Tigers are not a player away. They still have a long way to go.
 
I voted #2. He is still too young to move on from. He was better defensively last year and was one of their better hitters post all star break. I would give him one more year.
Last month though he batted .216 with a sub 100 OPS+. Which is one of his problems for his career inconsistency.
 
Id vote 2 as well, but this is it for him. I'm still not worried about his defense, but his bat needs to take a significant leap this year. He needs to at least get back to 2023 level tork. People need to forget about the #1 overall label. I feel he still has the talent to be an .800+ ops player and that would be huge for this team.
 
One burning question for each team at the Winter Meetings.
MLB.com
 
THE SHOPPING LIST.
Totally Tigers

The Winter Meetings start this coming weekend and it is when trades and free agent signings begin in earnest. Teams started the process at the earlier GM meetings and since then have been working the phones to pursue possible targets.
PoBO Scott Harris has his shopping list but of course it’s not as easy as finding players and signing them. Some may simply not want to come to Detroit. Others will have multiple bidders. Some GMs may not want to do business with Detroit or others will offer poor trade options.
Undoubtedly, Scott will be pivoting from 1 player to another as options disappear or suggested trades are deemed simply not worth it. Remember the old saying that sometimes the best trade is the one that wasn’t made.
So who will Harris be targeting? I’m sure some opportunities will present themselves that aren’t on his shopping list.
But here are his top priorities to try to bring home…..
 
THE SHOPPING LIST.
Totally Tigers

The Winter Meetings start this coming weekend and it is when trades and free agent signings begin in earnest. Teams started the process at the earlier GM meetings and since then have been working the phones to pursue possible targets.
PoBO Scott Harris has his shopping list but of course it’s not as easy as finding players and signing them. Some may simply not want to come to Detroit. Others will have multiple bidders. Some GMs may not want to do business with Detroit or others will offer poor trade options.
Undoubtedly, Scott will be pivoting from 1 player to another as options disappear or suggested trades are deemed simply not worth it. Remember the old saying that sometimes the best trade is the one that wasn’t made.
So who will Harris be targeting? I’m sure some opportunities will present themselves that aren’t on his shopping list.
But here are his top priorities to try to bring home…..
that "shopping list" is really long...and I agree with most of it. "adding 2-3 starting pitchers" should be #1 on the list. This team is still a work in progress and not close to being a contending team. They need to continue to build the farm system & upgrade some positions. They need to make small steps in getting to the ultimate goal, a team and organization that can have continued success.
 
One burning question for each team at the Winter Meetings.
MLB.com
 

Motor City Metrics Tigers Podcast: When do the Detroit Tigers actually start the hot stove in 2024? 65 minutes.
The MLB winter meetings kick up in Dallas starting next week. Are the Tigers ready to start making deals?
 
FIVE FOR FRIDAY.
Totally Tigers

The bar has been raised for who earns a spot on the Detroit Tigers’ roster. Starting this year, those who make the 2025 26-man roster will have increased competition.
And the decisions will become harder. In order to show improvement, some have to be cut so others can be added.
So which players are most likely to see themselves on the outside looking in?
I’ve got my list of 5.

But before I list them, there are some qualifiers:
– Those being cut have had to have some significant time playing in Detroit. Not just a small taste.
– There are those who are recovering from injuries and surgeries like Sawyer Gibson-Long who will get a longer leash and thus a more accurate assessment.
– Contracts like Javy Baez’s will not permit an outright DFA or trade to another team no matter how deserving. If there’s any movement, it won’t happen until spring training at the earliest.
– Player like Andy Ibanez and Zach McKinstry who just got raises are unlikely to be cut.
– Those who play crucial positions in which there are depth issues will stay with the team at least temporarily. Thus SSs like Ryan Kreidler will hang around, starting pitchers such as Matt Manning and Casey Mize along with catchers like Dillon Dingler. All safe until viable replacements are found or promoted. But if another team asks for one of these players to be included in a multi-trade deal then….
Without further adieu, here are my top 5 most likely to be traded:
 
FIVE FOR FRIDAY.
Totally Tigers

The bar has been raised for who earns a spot on the Detroit Tigers’ roster. Starting this year, those who make the 2025 26-man roster will have increased competition.
And the decisions will become harder. In order to show improvement, some have to be cut so others can be added.
So which players are most likely to see themselves on the outside looking in?
I’ve got my list of 5.

But before I list them, there are some qualifiers:
– Those being cut have had to have some significant time playing in Detroit. Not just a small taste.
– There are those who are recovering from injuries and surgeries like Sawyer Gibson-Long who will get a longer leash and thus a more accurate assessment.
– Contracts like Javy Baez’s will not permit an outright DFA or trade to another team no matter how deserving. If there’s any movement, it won’t happen until spring training at the earliest.
– Player like Andy Ibanez and Zach McKinstry who just got raises are unlikely to be cut.
– Those who play crucial positions in which there are depth issues will stay with the team at least temporarily. Thus SSs like Ryan Kreidler will hang around, starting pitchers such as Matt Manning and Casey Mize along with catchers like Dillon Dingler. All safe until viable replacements are found or promoted. But if another team asks for one of these players to be included in a multi-trade deal then….
Without further adieu, here are my top 5 most likely to be traded:
I would dump Kreidler before Tork
 
Back
Top