Welcome to Detroit Sports Forum!

By joining our community, you'll be able to connect with fellow fans that live and breathe Detroit sports just like you!

Get Started
  • If you are no longer able to access your account since our recent switch from vBulletin to XenForo, you may need to reset your password via email. If you no longer have access to the email attached to your account, please fill out our contact form and we will assist you ASAP. Thanks for your continued support of DSF.

Call Out Some Players

Depends on who he plays for. Nonetheless, he's played decent in 3 seasons, and more important has improved each year. As far as the NFC North, not as far as Rodgers is there. I think overall, the NFC is easier. So I believe they'd be a playoff team.

6 games against the weakest teams in the AFC. Stafford might look really good facing that division
 
Andrew Luck is probably the 3rd or 4th best QB in the NFL. Stafford is on the outside of the 10 somewhere. He's better in every way as a starting QB in the NFL, other than maybe arm strength. Mobile, strong as a freaking tank, football smart, and he's a winner. If you could trade the two straight up and add Luck to the Lions, and you said no, you'd be fired as a GM today. I know you like Matty Ice and that's fine, but he can't hold Luck's jock.

What exactly has Luck won btw? Certainly not a Super Bowl because thats all that matters.
I think Luck is a very good QB, but he coughs up the ball at an alarming rate. Worse than Stafford actually. AND he is constantly being surrounded by "weapons". That's a no no when it comes to you fucking brainiacs. Luck would get eaten alive in this town lol.

Luck is a winner....lmfao.
 
Watching the Titans/Colts game too right now. TY bailing out Luck on a throw downfield. Crazy familiar??
 
Maybe I'm going crazy, but didn't Luck win three playoff games in his first three years, including orchestrating one of the biggest comebacks in playoff history? Or did I dream that?

Meanwhile our guy hasn't won shit in six years.
 
Last edited:
Maybe I'm going crazy, but didn't Luck win three playoff games in his first three years

Sliding into the playoffs as a wildcard then getting humiliated by Brady show me that he belongs with QBs of that caliber. I just don't see him destroying teams like Rodgers, Brady, and Manning do. With how awful Green Bays defense is, how often do you see his team have to overcome huge defecits? You dont
 
Last edited:
Maybe I'm going crazy, but didn't Luck win three playoff games in his first three years, including orchestrating one of the biggest comebacks in playoff history? Or did I dream that?

Meanwhile our guy hasn't won shit in six years.

Stop comparing him to Stafford. I already know he's a better QB than Matt, but stop calling him a winner. Winners win Super Bowls....not just playoff games. Super Bowls!!
 
Watching the Titans/Colts game too right now. TY bailing out Luck on a throw downfield. Crazy familiar??

Since Stafford has only 4 attempts over 20 yards in 3 games, no it really doesn't. Feel free to elaborate.
 
Since Stafford has only 4 attempts over 20 yards in 3 games, no it really doesn't. Feel free to elaborate.

You need me to elaborate?? Have you watched Lions football through the years?? It's all people talk about when it pertains to Stafford. WRs bail him out all the time. I'm fine with that because i was trying to make a point that every QB in the NFL lofts up balls to his WRs. Not just Stafford.
 
You need me to elaborate?? Have you watched Lions football through the years?? It's all people talk about when it pertains to Stafford. WRs bail him out all the time. I'm fine with that because i was trying to make a point that every QB in the NFL lofts up balls to his WRs. Not just Stafford.

No, I don't really need you to elaborate, I was being cynical as to how this offense has been completely neutered. I'm far from a Stafford fan boy but nobody will convince me that his complete abandonment of the down field throw wasn't induced by Lombardi and/or Caldwell.
 
I don't know what the individual games look like but Luck's playoff stats aren't mind blowing, regardless his 3 wins.
 
No, I don't really need you to elaborate, I was being cynical as to how this offense has been completely neutered. I'm far from a Stafford fan boy but nobody will convince me that his complete abandonment of the down field throw wasn't induced by Lombardi and/or Caldwell.

I don't think anyone is trying to convince you of that, bro..lol. This shitshow is on Lombardi....and now it seems like Caldwell is a part of it too. He is the HC and the plays must go through him somewhat. This makes no sense.....CJ and Tate....2 burners and no deep balls to either of them. Who does Lombardi not trust? Stafford or the OLine? That's the 100 million dollar question. This is beyond bad.....wow.
 
just wanted to point out I said all of this about Lombardi last year when our offense was pathetic. Hes turned calvin into a piece of shit....I don't even know how that's possible....but he did it. Its the same shitty offense as last year only now their defense sucks too so were losing. You guys can all apologize now since you want to agree all of a sudden :D
 
Stop comparing him to Stafford. I already know he's a better QB than Matt, but stop calling him a winner. Winners win Super Bowls....not just playoff games. Super Bowls!!

this started when kdp1980 said he would take Stafford over Luck.
 
That's fine...so would I, but lets stop calling Luck a fucking winner. He hasn't won shite...

You would take Stafford over Luck?

As far as winning...he hasn't won a SB but he has certainly won more playoff games than Stafford. My guess is he has beaten a winning team on the road as well.
 
I don't think anyone is trying to convince you of that, bro..lol. This shitshow is on Lombardi....and now it seems like Caldwell is a part of it too. He is the HC and the plays must go through him somewhat. This makes no sense.....CJ and Tate....2 burners and no deep balls to either of them. Who does Lombardi not trust? Stafford or the OLine? That's the 100 million dollar question. This is beyond bad.....wow.
Lombardi doesn't trust Staff, OLine, or himself. Now Tate running his mouth. This is bad.

Sent from my XT1254 using Tapatalk
 
You would take Stafford over Luck?

As far as winning...he hasn't won a SB but he has certainly won more playoff games than Stafford. My guess is he has beaten a winning team on the road as well.

No...sorry, i would take Luck over Stafford
 
Back
Top