Matthew Stafford comes in as No. 9 QB in NFL

[tomdalton22]

Maholmes had better weapon health around him and plays in a shit division

weapon health and shit division. Are those new excuses or old ones? I have a really hard time keeping up with your shitty excuses.

:lmao:

 

[LKP]

weapon health and shit division. Are those new excuses or old ones? I have a really hard time keeping up with your shitty excuses.

:lmao:

I don't need an excuse. Stafford had a higher QB rating than Maholmes in 2019. 2018 Stafford clearly had weapons around him get hurt all over the place and played with a bad back hurting his QB rating.

Give me Stafford and his contract all day over Maholmes and his contract.

Stafford higher QB rating in 2017

By the way, KC QB Alex Smith had the highest QB rating in the league in 2017. Maybe its the team surrounding the QB

 

[Mitchrapp]

Maholmes had better weapon health around him and plays in a shit division

He won a Super Bowl.

 

[tomdalton22]

I don't need an excuse. Stafford had a higher QB rating than Maholmes in 2019. 2018 Stafford clearly had weapons around him get hurt all over the place and played with a bad back hurting his QB rating.

Give me Stafford and his contract all day over Maholmes and his contract.

Stafford higher QB rating in 2017

By the way, KC QB Alex Smith had the highest QB rating in the league in 2017. Maybe its the team surrounding the QB

lol...compare 2017 QB ratings. Mahomes' rookie year when he only played in one game.

:tup:

Mahomes has played in 2 full seasons. He won the MVP in the first season and a SB in the second. He is already a more decorated QB than Matt.

As far as contracts...would I rather have Mahomes or Stafford? I think you have to take everything into consideration. Stafford has already earned $211M and he has exactly zero playoff wins, zero MVPs, zero SB titles, Zero all pros. He does have one NFC offensive player of the week award and a pro bowl alternate in 2014 :clap:

I'd take Mahomes and his contract at the age of 24 over Matt at 32 and what the Lions will probably end up paying him over the rest of his career.

Stick to comparing Matt to guys at his level. Guys like Andy Dalton, Curt Cousins, Ryan Tannehill, James Winston, Derick Carr....guys like that. Don't bring up the elite guys...you look stupid.

 

[LKP]

lol...compare 2017 QB ratings. Mahomes' rookie year when he only played in one game.

:tup:

Mahomes has played in 2 full seasons. He won the MVP in the first season and a SB in the second. He is already a more decorated QB than Matt.

As far as contracts...would I rather have Mahomes or Stafford? I think you have to take everything into consideration. Stafford has already earned $211M and he has exactly zero playoff wins, zero MVPs, zero SB titles, Zero all pros. He does have one NFC offensive player of the week award and a pro bowl alternate in 2014 :clap:

I'd take Mahomes and his contract at the age of 24 over Matt at 32 and what the Lions will probably end up paying him over the rest of his career.

Stick to comparing Matt to guys at his level. Guys like Andy Dalton, Curt Cousins, Ryan Tannehill, James Winston, Derick Carr....guys like that. Don't bring up the elite guys...you look stupid.

Stafford better QB rating than Maholmes 2019. Fact

Teams win championships not QBs. Alex Smith had the highest QB rating in 2017 on the Chiefs. Maholmes fell into a great situation. Stafford is better.

 

[tomdalton22]

Stafford better QB rating than Maholmes

Stafford is better.

Stafford 89.3
Mahomes 108.9

 

[LKP]

Stafford 89.3
Mahomes 108.9

Based on Staffords play his QB rating is 110+. Based on the team and injuries and 2009 rookie season on a terrible team it falls to 89.3. Stafford is better 2 of the last 3 seasons in fact.

Stafford will have a higher QB rating in 2020 as well. Bet on that

 

[tomdalton22]

Based on Staffords play his QB rating is 110+. Based on the team and injuries and 2009 rookie season on a terrible team it falls to 89.3. Stafford is better 2 of the last 3 seasons in fact.

Stafford will have a higher QB rating in 2020 as well. Bet on that

he was better in 2017...Mahomes played in one game.
2018 Mahomes was much better...MVP
2019 Mahomes was much better since Stafford couldn't stay healthy.

2020...only time will tell.

 

[Mitchrapp]

he was better in 2017...Mahomes played in one game.
2018 Mahomes was much better...MVP
2019 Mahomes was much better since Stafford couldn't stay healthy.

2020...only time will tell. NO

:nod:

 

[kalinecountry]

https://www.prideofdetroit.com/2020...act-predictions-patrick-mahomes-detroit-lions
What could Matthew Stafford?s next deal look like?
Remember when Stafford was the highest-paid quarterback? That didn?t last long.
POD

https://lionswire.usatoday.com/2020...o-longer-close-to-the-top-10-amongst-nfl-qbs/
Matthew Stafford's contract no longer close to the top 10 amongst NFL QBs.
LionsWire

 

[LKP]

he was better in 2017...Mahomes played in one game.
2018 Mahomes was much better...MVP
2019 Mahomes was much better since Stafford couldn't stay healthy.

2020...only time will tell.

Stafford outplayed Maholmes in 2019 and 2017. 2018 Stafford had weapons injuries galore around him and played hurt. Maholmes gets 2018

Maholmes is good but Stafford has been slightly better. We'll see in 2020. If Stafford does outperform him again, it will be 3 of last 4 years. Can't wait

 

[tomdalton22]

Stafford outplayed Maholmes in 2019 and 2017. 2018 Stafford had weapons injuries galore around him and played hurt. Maholmes gets 2018

based on your "logic" Ryan Tannehill & Matt Schaub were better than Stafford last year. :tup:

 

[mhughes0021]

Remember when Matt Flynn beat Stafford to win the division. You think Mahomes would ever let that happen?

Team game....remember when Stafford had the #2 defense in the league? Howd that work out for him?

 

[LKP]

based on your "logic" Ryan Tannehill & Matt Schaub were better than Stafford last year. :tup:

Schaub didn't have enough passes to qualify.
Tannenhill had a good year after many poor years. Stafford has been better most of his career. Just like Stafford has been better than Maholmes 2 of the last 3 years

 

[tomdalton22]

Schaub didn't have enough passes to qualify.
Tannenhill had a good year after many poor years. Stafford has been better most of his career. Just like Stafford has been better than Maholmes 2 of the last 3 years

last year Tannehill > Stafford :tup:

 

[LKP]

last year Tannehill > Stafford :tup:

Due to the focus on Derek Henry opening thing up for Tannehill. But yes Stafford and Tannehill and Maholmes all very good QBs last year

 

[mhughes0021]

Due to the focus on Derek Henry opening thing up for Tannehill. But yes Stafford and Tannehill and Maholmes all very good QBs last year

Stafford didnt have enough passes to qualify.

 

[LKP]

Stafford didnt have enough passes to qualify.

Yes Stafford had plenty of passes to qualify which is why he ranks 6th in the league in QB rating ahead of Maholmes under qualified passers

 

[tomdalton22]

Stafford didnt have enough passes to qualify.

don't forget that our slow witted friend claims that passer rating is a team stat when it doesn't suit his narrative.

Nobody with a brain thinks Stafford is a better QB than Mahomes.

 

[mhughes0021]

Yes Stafford had plenty of passes to qualify which is why he ranks 6th in the league in QB rating ahead of Maholmes under qualified passers

8 games played. 3 wins. Who cares.