Welcome to Detroit Sports Forum!

By joining our community, you'll be able to connect with fellow fans that live and breathe Detroit sports just like you!

Get Started
  • If you are no longer able to access your account since our recent switch from vBulletin to XenForo, you may need to reset your password via email. If you no longer have access to the email attached to your account, please fill out our contact form and we will assist you ASAP. Thanks for your continued support of DSF.

PFF Review Week 2

grandy

Senior Member
Joined
Aug 4, 2011
Messages
11,699
ReFo: Lions @ Panthers, Week 2
Cole Schultz | September 15, 2014

One of the most popular picks to regress in 2014, the Panthers quieted there doubters with a strong defensive performance against a hot Lions team coming off a beat down of the Giants.

One week removed from a 35-point display in primetime, Detroit fell flat against a stingy Carolina defense, ending the afternoon with just seven points to show for their work. As has become the norm in recent seasons, mistakes plagued an otherwise talented club, as the Lions aided the Panthers? strong defensive work by dropping numerous passes, fumbling, and even missing a field goal for good measure.

Which isn?t to say that the Panthers were perfect. What they did do was minimize the impact of the mistakes they made and forced Matthew Stafford and company to methodically move down the field, something they couldn?t execute consistently. The Panthers? secondary, their biggest defensive weakness, held Detroit?s high flying passing attack to just one completion over 20 yards. This win puts Carolina at 2-0 as they head into a very rough stretch of schedule, while Detroit ends up in a four-way tie for the NFC North lead after crashing back down to earth.

Detroit Lions?Performances of Note

Nick Fairley, DT: +1.2

Breakdown: Much was made of Fairley taking snaps with the second team in practice during the preseason amid concerns of his physical condition. And while the camera crew found opportunities to show Fairley panting on the sideline, he was an effective player for the 32 snaps he made it on the field. Generating consistent push against the run, Fairly was disruptive as Carolina was never able to establish a consistent running attack.

Signature Play: With 8:12 to go in the final quarter, Fairley blew up a 2nd-and-goal play from the 1-yard line, shooting inside Byron Bell and stonewalling Mike Tolbert for a 4-yard loss.

Matthew Stafford, QB: -4.6 passing

Breakdown: Just when you think Stafford is going to put everything together and become a top-tier quarterback, he puts forth a performance like this. His receiving corps didn?t do him any favors with several drops, but all too often Stafford resorted to forcing throws to Calvin Johnson, a strategy that has routinely exhibited mixed results.

Signature Play: With 1:11 to go in the first half, Stafford fired into double coverage aiming for Johnson. Melvin White undercut the route perfectly only for another defender to deflect the pass before he had a chance to pick it off.

Brandon Pettigrew, TE: +0.2

Breakdown: Playing just a shade over half of the Lions? 73 offensive snaps, Pettigrew is on pace for his lowest full-season snap count since his rookie season in 2009. He played more than both Eric Ebron and Joseph Fauria, but fewer passing downs than Ebron. Detroit?s offense had a pass-to-run ratio of more than 3:1, and though this game was a bit extreme, it shouldn?t be too far off what to expect from the Lions. It will be interesting to see what Detroit plans to do with Pettigrew in the coming weeks/years, as the other two have either higher upside (Ebron) or a friendlier contract (Fauria), and especially at tight end, three?s a crowd.

Signature Stat: Dropped the only pass thrown his way.

Carolina Panthers?Performances of Note

Kelvin Benjamin, WR: -0.1

Breakdown: A final grade of -0.1 seems like a boring day, right? Well as it turns out, Benjamin was anything but. He frustratingly dropped three passes, but rewarded Cam Newton?s faith in him with a spectacular one-handed sideline grab against a shocked Rashean Mathis. His only other catch moved the chains, and several of his drops would have too, indicating an ability to get open. The potential is there.

Signature Play: Fourth quarter, 12:16 to go. One of the best catches of the weekend.

Greg Olsen, TE: +2.7

Breakdown: Many feared (rightly so) what the departure of Steve Smith would have on an already thin receiving corps, but it helps to have arguably the most underrated tight end in the league. Olsen led the team with six catches, picking up four first downs and drawing a flagrant defensive holding call on what likely would have been a touchdown.

Signature Play: On Carolina?s two-point conversion to Jerricho Cotchery on a shallow crossing pattern, Olsen ran his hitch perfectly to impede Darius Slay?s attempt at tracking Cotchery across the goal line, leading to an easy score.

Mario Addison, DE: +0.8

Breakdown: Without Greg Hardy in the lineup, the Panthers turned to Addison as part of a three-man rotation at end opposite Charles Johnson. Though some of it was in garbage time, Addison tallied four sacks as he worked over Detroit?s tackles.

Signature Stat: On the field for only three running plays compared to 27 passes.

PFF Game Ball

Luke Kuechly (+2.6) was an integral part of Carolina?s defensive dominance, performing well in coverage and against the run.

https://www.profootballfocus.com/blog/2014/09/15/refo-lions-panthers-week-2/
 
Brandon Pettigrew, TE: +0.2

Signature Stat: Dropped the only pass thrown his way.

LKP: Pettigrew wont drop passes anymore.

Ummmm....ERRRR.....WRONG!
 
OH fuck....now Tony has to write PFF and tell them how wrong they are about Stafford.
 
Brandon Pettigrew, TE: +0.2

Signature Stat: Dropped the only pass thrown his way.

LKP: Pettigrew wont drop passes anymore.

Ummmm....ERRRR.....WRONG!

I never said he wouldn't drop anymore passes. Hughes making up shit again.

10 incompletions were Staffords fault including the pick. 11 were not. And of course the 27 completions. Stafford played well enough to win, the team let him down this week.
 
OH fuck....now Tony has to write PFF and tell them how wrong they are about Stafford.

I don't have to write shit about anybody. All of a sudden you're taking PFF's words as gospel?? Of course you are!!! lmao.

I admitted Stafford wasn't very good in the second half of that game. He wasn't the reason why we lost, but he needs to be better. Overall, he played pretty damn good against a top 10 defense, he just needs to clean up a bit.
 
I don't have to write shit about anybody. All of a sudden you're taking PFF's words as gospel?? Of course you are!!! lmao.

I admitted Stafford wasn't very good in the second half of that game. He wasn't the reason why we lost, but he needs to be better. Overall, he played pretty damn good against a top 10 defense, he just needs to clean up a bit.

Hmm..forcing passes to Megatron. Perfect recipe for success or failure
 
Staff was ok, 3 of first 4 drives were over 50 yards ending in missed fgs ?nd bell fumble, throw in cj dropped td
 
Last edited:
I don't have to write shit about anybody. All of a sudden you're taking PFF's words as gospel?? Of course you are!!! lmao.

I admitted Stafford wasn't very good in the second half of that game. He wasn't the reason why we lost, but he needs to be better. Overall, he played pretty damn good against a top 10 defense, he just needs to clean up a bit.

Top ten defense or not, Stafford doesn't beat good teams. That's gotta change
 
Last edited:
Staff was ok, 3 of first 4 drives were over 50 yards ending in missed figs ?nd bell fumble, throw in cj dropped td

Lost by damn near 3 tds, Stafford was what he's always been, average.
 
Overall, he did not play pretty damn good against a top 10 defense. He was below average. If that's what "pretty damn good" is, it's going to be a longggggg season.
 
Hmm..forcing passes to Megatron. Perfect recipe for success or failure

Greatest WR in the world. He's going to force them every now and then. You'd be complaining if CJ wasn't getting enough looks, so stop it.
 
Overall, he did not play pretty damn good against a top 10 defense. He was below average. If that's what "pretty damn good" is, it's going to be a longggggg season.

He was good enough. Should have been over 60% completion, over 300 yds and at least 2 TDS. Drops and fumbles killing him again as usual. He did his job.
 
13 targets on 48 attempts. That's not really forcing.
 
Not sure why there is an argument here.
-Stafford wasn't good enough
-Calvin wasn't good enough
-Bell wasn't good enough
-RT wasn't good enough

I thought Tate played well enough, looked like he was open a few times in the second half, just stopped going to him. However that could be incorrect, hard to definitively tell from TV feed.

You can excuse RT, you expect struggles from backups and young guys.
Defense played well enough for us to win.

It wasn't loss because of one player.
 
Because there are a few people on this forum that say Stafford WAS good enough.
 
If you must put it on one player the only one you can put it on is Stafford in my opinion.

Would we of won if we changed one WR?
Would we of won if we had a different RT?
Would we of won if we had McCoy at RB?
Would we of won with Richard Sherman?

My opinion if you only chose one of those, no they wouldn't of made a difference.

Would we of won with Peyton Manning?
I believe we would of, QB can make that much of a difference in my opinion. That is the one position you could change out and make the biggest difference.
 
Stafford was good enough week 2. But could be much better too.
 
Back
Top