Welcome to Detroit Sports Forum!

By joining our community, you'll be able to connect with fellow fans that live and breathe Detroit sports just like you!

Get Started
  • If you are no longer able to access your account since our recent switch from vBulletin to XenForo, you may need to reset your password via email. If you no longer have access to the email attached to your account, please fill out our contact form and we will assist you ASAP. Thanks for your continued support of DSF.

MSU pres. Resigns

interesting points brought up

OTL had to wait until after the Nasser situation was final. Had to wait until after the sentencing. OTL had to wait as to not to be thought of as an influence to that case. This is what I'm reading.

As far as Dantonio kicking the 4 off the team. That really didn't matter at all. The title IX decision would've done that anyway. Dantonio just got out in front of that. It would've been hard for him to keep them after they were expelled from the university.
 
interesting points brought up

OTL had to wait until after the Nasser situation was final. Had to wait until after the sentencing. OTL had to wait as to not to be thought of as an influence to that case. This is what I'm reading.

Do you actually believe that? The press was silenced or they silenced themselves so as not to influence the Nassar case with a bunch of unrelated, already investigated and reported cases?

As far as Dantonio kicking the 4 off the team. That really didn't matter at all. The title IX decision would've done that anyway. Dantonio just got out in front of that. It would've been hard for him to keep them after they were expelled from the university.

ah, so he didn't do it because he was following protocol and it was the right thing to do, he did it to get ahead of the Title IX investigation - probably in the hopes that he wouldn't later be linked to the Nassar scandal.
 
strange aside or maybe not: the former assistant prosecuting attorney that decided to not press charges in the Payne/Appling case is now an employee of Michigan State University

strange!
 
That's a possibility, they were both dismissed from the program, but at different times. Allen was trying to work his way back over the summer, then let go, Lucious was dismissed the day before we played UM in EL.

The popular explanation among MSU fans was that they smoked a lot of pot, hardly a big deal really, but that's what we thought. Izzo was interviewed after Lucious was dismissed, he said something along the lines of "when you cut ties with a player, it's never the first or second thing they've done, they've usually wasted a number of chances"

that's pure speculation on them being involved, but it's plausible. honestly, it would be a gift to Izzo if it was them. We can show that although no charges were filed, they were kicked off the team.

If memory serves me correctly, didn?t lucious get kicked off midway through 2011 for stealing something as well?
 
Do you actually believe that? The press was silenced or they silenced themselves so as not to influence the Nassar case with a bunch of unrelated, already investigated and reported cases?



ah, so he didn't do it because he was following protocol and it was the right thing to do, he did it to get ahead of the Title IX investigation - probably in the hopes that he wouldn't later be linked to the Nassar scandal.

Circle the wagons, brah!!

I won't engage trolls. I was only discussing things with sbee, because i thought he might be able to provide some timeline information that I was missing. Now it seems that we've met with the limit of his knowledge, so I'll go back to only discussing this with people I feel are logical posters, both Michigan and some MSU posters.
 
@Bry_Mac has some interesting tweets on the subject.
 
Last edited:
Dantonio suspended the 3 before the title 9 investigation, he called the title 9 office himself. Saying that he didn't handle this properly is way off base. He heard about it, immediately suspended the players right away, called the title 9 office and the players were removed from student housing pending investigation. Once charges were filed, they were dismissed before having their day in court. They very well may be acquitted. The ironic and sad thing was that 2 weeks before he had a speaker come in to talk about the Minnesota situation and how to avoid that.

Please answer me how that could have been handled better.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G900A using Tapatalk
 
That Mark Dantonio, he is such a tough disciplinarian. He kicked those players off the team, 2 weeks before they were to be expelled. Fine job, coach D.
 
That Mark Dantonio, he is such a tough disciplinarian. He kicked those players off the team, 2 weeks before they were to be expelled. Fine job, coach D.

Again, how could he have handled the situation better?

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G900A using Tapatalk
 
How mamy times did Msu sue to keep information withheld? Because it really is a bad look if there is nothing to hide. Open the books and come clean on everything . If Mark and Tom have nothing to hide then what is there to worry about ?
 
Circle the wagons, brah!!

I won't engage trolls. I was only discussing things with sbee, because i thought he might be able to provide some timeline information that I was missing. Now it seems that we've met with the limit of his knowledge, so I'll go back to only discussing this with people I feel are logical posters, both Michigan and some MSU posters.

Those were honest questions. Those explanations seem a bit ridiculous and I was wondering how they could be taken seriously. If you believe them, you're missing more than timeline information. If I was trolling you I would have said something like "you've been reading it? Interesting, I didn't know coloring books had words in them." Then I would have said you have to be really stupid to believe those explanations and even dumber to admit to other people that you consider them plausible.
 
Last edited:
How mamy times did Msu sue to keep information withheld? Because it really is a bad look if there is nothing to hide. Open the books and come clean on everything . If Mark and Tom have nothing to hide then what is there to worry about ?

Nothing. The investigations have all been disclosed. The only ones who have definitely withheld facts in the MD and TO instances is ESPN.
 
Nothing. The investigations have all been disclosed. The only ones who have definitely withheld facts in the MD and TO instances is ESPN.

This is not true at all Msu sued espn at least 2 or 3 times to block ESPN from getting the information they requested . Notice the word some . It is a flat out lie that msu turned over all the information without a fight for it.

May 2nd 2017
https://www.lansingstatejournal.com...-sex-assault-investigation-records/101201004/

If espn is in the wrong then Msu should sue them for defamation. So the question is this . If Mark or Tom have anything to hide lawyer up and sue espn again. Mark seems pretty defiant he did nothing wrong so maybe you and sbee are right and this will all blow over and Mark, Tom, and MSu can sue ESPN for millions if they have nothing to hide.
My Speculation is that your president, and AD retire , and resign in the same week there are skeleton's in the closet. Come clean and lay everything on the table. The Truth will set you free !!!!!
 
Last edited:
I think any program would do the same thing. Would you want the reasoning for every "violation of team rules" made public? Also, there were no charges in almost all of these cases so you're protecting the identity of people who didn't get charged with a crime.



Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G900A using Tapatalk
 
He's totally letting Fandom get in the way, he's a spartan who hates MSU. He refuses to believe the prosecutor about Appling and Payne and he also thinks MD doesn't punish players when they screw up. I wonder if he ever heard of Evans and Sweat?

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G900A using Tapatalk
 
"As long as you don't get caught by the police, you're OK to do whatever you want." This is what is being taught these days

Nobody ever gets away with anything

coaches sometimes know more than the police in these situations
 
I think any program would do the same thing. Would you want the reasoning for every "violation of team rules" made public? Also, there were no charges in almost all of these cases so you're protecting the identity of people who didn't get charged with a crime.



Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G900A using Tapatalk

Maybe once but not a bunch of times and no I do not think the guy litered. So you don't think Walton hit the girl 1 or 2 times in the bar ? You believe Payne when he said he stopped but his roommate (Appling) wanted more sex so we are lead to believe Keith talked her into more consensual sex? That is such bullshit that you believe both players but not the girl when she said NO!!!

Talk about fandom you're all over this message board protecting MSU when both the president and the AD resigned in one week. Wtf sbee .People dont so that unless they are worried about Something. Especially the AD.
So don't sit here and think Msu is not in trouble . Oh and btw I do not want either Mark or Tom fired at all but if they have not done nothing wrong then you have nothing to worry about and they can lawyer up and msu can Sue ESPN.
 
Last edited:
Maybe once but not a bunch of times and no I do not think the guy litered. So you don't think Walton hit the girl 1 or 2 times in the bar ? You believe Payne when he said he stopped but his roommate (Appling) wanted more sex so we are lead to believe Keith talked her into more consensual sex? That is such bullshit that you believe both players but not the girl when she said NO!!!

Talk about fandom you're all over this message board protecting MSU when both the president and the AD resigned in one week. Wtf sbee .People dont so that unless they are worried about Something. Especially the AD.
So don't sit here and think Msu is not in trouble . Oh and btw I do not want either Mark or Tom fired at all but if they have not done nothing wrong then you have nothing to worry about and they can lawyer up and msu can Sue ESPN.

Bob, you simply don't know the cases. As for Walton, I've said Izzo needs to answer some questions about him, why he was allowed to coach after the accusation of hitting the woman. I am ok with an answer saying they let the legal process play out and allowed him to coach while that was happening, there is innocence until proof of guilt. I can live with that one. The one that concerns me is the Walton rape allegation with two other players, from what I can tell is that a letter came to MSU about 15 months after it allegedly took place. I need to see how that was handled before I say Izzo should survive this. Please don't accuse me of just being a fan here, these programs are important to me and I absolutely love Izzo, but I am also saying that there may be damaging info out there that he can't recover from and may deserve to be let go, we don't know yet. That is not what a blind fanboy would say.

On the Appling and Payne case, I trust the prosecutor's office's assessment of the situation, that no crime occurred. The woman did not say "stop" as you said, she engaged in consensual sex with the players and at one point said that she was "done." none of the reports said that she said no, so that's factually incorrect. She said that she felt like she wasn't free to leave, although she never said that the players told her she had to stay or that she was restrained. If you don't trust the legal process on this one, I'd say you're being a fan more than being objective. They were legally cleared, I don't expect Izzo to suspend players who were exonerated through the legal system.

I am not saying that they've done nothing wrong, I need more info, at least on Izzo. I'm confident in how MD handled things, especially when you consider what ESPN left out of their story.

As for Simon and Hollis stepping down, they stepped down because of the public outcry and mob mentality. Simon was alerted of a title 9 investigation into an unnamed doctor in 2014, the title 9 office cleared Nassar. What was Simon supposed to do? Until I see proof that she was told before 2014, I stand by the fact that she shouldn't have stepped down. As for Hollis, I'm in wait and see mode with him. If there is evidence that he did cover up the Walton accusation or didn't report it properly, then he should have stepped down. As it relates to Nassar, I don't see Hollis being responsible. Doctors and trainers report up through the college of Osteopathic Medicine, not through the athletic department. Saying it happened under his watch is inaccurate.

Again, I'm not saying they did everything right, this Walton accusation may be the end of Izzo and that would be very hard to deal with. We need to hear from him, hopefully soon.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top