Stafford Tops Sporting News' Overrated QB List

[tomdalton22]

You are right. It's 24 not 23.

10 points by offense with Stafford contributing to the 10.

4 more from Neal sack instead of just the made FG (FG becomes TD).

14 true points

3 more more from missed FG

17 true points

and 7 more from stip sack by Pepper (no points to 7)

24 true points

Give Stafford another 3 for Fuller int too because if he caught it, then they are in FG range

27 true points in Week 3. Final score Lions 27 Packers 7

Classic LKP...what a fucking moron!

 

[LKP]

Classic LKP...what a fucking moron!

Game tape shows Stafford scored 27.

Packer got "lucky" we had a third string rookie RT and Freese couldn't kick. Lions still won 19-7 anyway. I was at the game. It was beautiful.

 

[brewer229]

Game tape shows Stafford scored 27.

Packer got "lucky" we had a third string rookie RT and Freese couldn't kick. Lions still won 19-7 anyway. I was at the game. It was beautiful.

 

[tonyballs]

I think FF has something to do with his perception. People that don't follow the Lions think he is great...maybe FF has a lot to do with that.

Then those people are stupid.

 

[tonyballs]

20 QB's, and my Mom>>Matt.

Name those 20 QBs again, please?

 

[cheeno]

Name those 20 QBs again, please?

http://espn.go.com/nfl/qbr

 

[tonyballs]

http://espn.go.com/nfl/qbr

No no no, I was asking him to name 20 QBs better than Stafford. Or 20 QBs you'd rather have over Stafford. I should have clarified....

And Mark Sanchez? Really? Lol

QBR is a joke of a stat

 

[boogerlovejoy]

No no no, I was asking him to name 20 QBs better than Stafford. Or 20 QBs you'd rather have over Stafford. I should have clarified....

And Mark Sanchez? Really? Lol

QBR is a joke of a stat

QBR is a joke.

The best game ever recorded by QBR is by Charlie Batch. He was 12-17 for 186 yards....3 TD and 2 INT's in a game that was 38-6 until late in the 4th (38-13 final)

http://espn.go.com/nfl/boxscore?gameId=300926027

Really? That's the best game a qb has had in 8 years???? He scored a 99.9 in that game. Awesome.

Yeah.....I never look at QBR.

 

[dtroitlionsfan951]

Dan orlovsky had a better qbr than Ben roethlisberger the same year that we went 0-16 and he won 12 games and the super bowl.

 

[cheeno]

Yeah I hate QBR, I like the traditional passer rating much better.

http://espn.go.com/nfl/statistics/player/_/stat/passing/sort/quarterbackRating

 

[boogerlovejoy]

Dan orlovsky had a better qbr than Ben roethlisberger the same year that we went 0-16 and he won 12 games and the super bowl.

Well, clearly, Orlovsky is a better QB.

DUH!!!

QBR says so!!!

 

[cheeno]

Well, clearly, Orlovsky is a better QB.

DUH!!!

QBR says so!!!

Passer rating says Stafford is 21st overall. QBR boosted him to 20th.

 

[inkfreq]

I'm just stunned we've hit 18 pages based on an editorial/opinion piece run is America's least valuable sports publication.

Really... The Sporting News?

Let me know next week what the National Enquirer thinks of Calvin Johnson, because it would at least be slightly more reputable.

 

[cheeno]

I'm just stunned we've hit 18 pages based on an editorial/opinion piece run is America's least valuable sports publication.

Really... The Sporting News?

Let me know next week what the National Enquirer thinks of Calvin Johnson, because it would at least be slightly more reputable.

That's explains why they were so late to the party. Everyone has known Stafford is the John Daly of football for years.

 

[boogerlovejoy]

I'm just stunned we've hit 18 pages based on an editorial/opinion piece run is America's least valuable sports publication.

Really... The Sporting News?

Let me know next week what the National Enquirer thinks of Calvin Johnson, because it would at least be slightly more reputable.

I love whenever Stafford is mentioned in a thread. It always turns into an argument between LKP and the downers....

He is great.....

He is average to slightly below average.....

Tape says if everything is perfect and goes his way......he is elite......

Top 20, my aunt, Mark Sanchez.......

LOL......it never ends!

 

[grandy]

I'm just stunned we've hit 18 pages based on an editorial/opinion piece run is America's least valuable sports publication.

Really... The Sporting News?

Let me know next week what the National Enquirer thinks of Calvin Johnson, because it would at least be slightly more reputable.

I made this thread knowing how it would eventually turn out.

And yes, I am a terrible person.

 

[Mitchrapp]

QBR, in one example, hits hard on sacks. Whether it was the QB's fault or not. Not sure why they created it.

 

[Mitchrapp]

That's explains why they were so late to the party. Everyone has known Stafford is the John Daly of football for years.

I wish, Daly has 2 Major Championships.

 

[dtroitlionsfan951]

QBR, in one example, hits hard on sacks. Whether it was the QB's fault or not. Not sure why they created it.

They attempted to make a situational stat without adding in all situations. Makes sense right?

 

[cheeno]

I wish, Daly has 2 Major Championships.

Stafford has 2 playoff appearances, if you ask LKP (or the banners at Ford Field) that's just as good.